Masterpiece Comics
Re-imagine this book as a comic book. What comic book would it be? What superheroes would the characters be? Who would be the villain? What comic book themes would we need to address?
Take a few minutes and come up with a list of comics, superheroes, and villains that would work for our novel.
Creating Structure
How To Write Anything pg. 200
Creating Structure. The structure of an analysis of literature can head in various directions. You can present a string of evidence to support a claim. You can examine similarities and differences. You can ask a question and explore ideas rather than a single point. In all these, you need to support a claim with reasons and evidence from the text.
You can think of these as the “chips and salsa” of a paragraph. The chips can be the reason supporting the claim and the salsa can be the textual evidence, quotes, lines, ideas, paraphrases, chapters, etc that support the reason.
- Introduction leading to claim
- First supporting reason + textual evidence
- Supporting reason + evidence
- 3rd, 4th, 5th supporting reasons + evidence for each
- Conclusion connecting the parts and making the argument clear. Answer the “So what?” question and give the significance. Why does this matter? Why should we care? What should we take away from your analysis? How does it help us understand the literary work better?
This is just one sample structure. You decide what the reasons and evidence are and how to organize the argument best. What do you need to so to prove your reading of the text?
Use a formal style. (pg. 202)
Cite your evidence using MLA citations. (pg. 472)
Example:
- Rowell provides many examples of domestic violence (50).
- Eleanor & Park
provides many examples of domestic violence (Rowell 50).
Discuss Chapters 42, 43, and 45
Chapter 42 Summarizing Sources
Summarize key scenes to support your claims and reasons.
Chapter 43 Paraphrasing Sources
Paraphrase evidence when it is not necessary to use exact wording. Quote when it is specific or important to maintain the language.
Chapter 45 Documenting Sources
In academia, we cite where the ideas, points, evidence comes from. We are always writing within a pre-existing discussion. You want to cite others to borrow their credibility.
Outline Workshop
Workshop looking for structure and evidence, “Chips and Salsa” for your essay. Make it detailed. Add in specific scenes, lines, evidence. What do you still need to research?
Thesis Statements
TWO FAIRLY EASY WAYS TO CREATE AN ARGUABLE THESIS:
1) Use “should”, “must”, “needs to” to reveal the imperative that you’re arguing for:
Example: The Klamath River must be given sufficient water to avoid further salmon die-offs, as happened recently.
2) Add your opposition to your thesis, so we know what the opposing argument is early on:
Example: Although the farmers and other competing water interests would argue against this, the Klamath River must be given sufficient water to avoid further salmon die-offs, as happened recently.
Write a Thesis
- Focused
- Debatable
- Picks a side
- Makes a claim
- Supported by evidence
Write
Comment below with your outline for points.
Also, did you provide sufficient reasons and evidence to support your claim? Is there anything you still need to cover to make sure the readers of your essay can follow along? Did you answer any questions you raised?
Homework
- Revise Essay
- Read Chapter 36, Peer Editing
outline
1 intro
-the american dream
-arturo embodies the theme which is the american dream
2 what is the american dream
-and what does it mean through out the novel
3 arturo is successful
-he owned land in mexico
-now he a mushroom farmer
4 arturo came to the us for maribel not for money.
-maribel had a brain injury which affected her learning
-arturo came for a better education for maribel
5 the author of the book her dad came from mexico illegally
-she understand that many people define the american dream as just being successful but race has to do with it.
-she established the theme of the american dream and family though out her novel.
LikeLike
Alma keeps secrets to herself to protect her family.
Because Alma feels guilty, she keeps some things to herself that ultimately turn out to be bad.
LikeLike
Outline
I. Bullying Intro/Thesis
II. Define the issue bullying form within the text
III. Define bullying
IV. Why is bullying an issue?
V. A case of bullying to suicide
VI. What can be done to entirely eradicate bullying/conclusion?
LikeLike
Outline
1. Intro/Thesis – Peer Pressure
2. examples of Mayor experiencing pressure from his parents, classmates, and himself.
3. Examples of real world peer pressure to real people
4. consequences of peer pressure
LikeLike
Thesis: Cristina puts these brief stories about the extra characters to show the reader the reality of being an immigrant, to show them that life is hardly what you expect it to be. But that’s okay, because we as people do our best to come to terms with that, so we can move on.
1. First Paragraph, intro
Intro to the book.
Brief summary of book
Talk about the characters in the book and show their similarity
Thesis on hope.
2. First Body
Give first example of Hope
DIscuss how it affected the character
Discuss how they only see the positive in their situation even though it isn’t what they wanted
3. Second body
Give second example of Hope
DIscuss how it affected the character
Discuss how they only see the positive in their situation even though it isn’t what they wanted
4.Third body
Give third example of lack of hope
DIscuss how it affected the character
Discuss how they only see the positive in their situation even though it isn’t what they wanted
5. Fourth body
Tell the reader about alma’s hope
DIscuss how it affected the character
Discuss how they only see the positive in their situation even though it isn’t what they wanted
6. Outro
Discuss previous points
Recap on how they relate to alma
Recap outside examples
LikeLike
I. Introduction/Thesis
a. Why do immigrants come to America?
i. Safe haven, education, jobs/career, opportunity, health, children’s future
II. Safe Haven
a. Bad situation back in homeland
i. Government taking away human rights
ii. Killings/genocide and wars, revolution
iii. Financial burdens, difficulty making money to survive
iv. Scarce source of food/water
v. Unstable homes
b. Reasons to get out of the situation
i. Danger, living situations, food/shelter
III. Education
a. Limited education, rules and regulations such as certain laws.
b. Financial burdens
IV. Jobs and Career
a. Financial stability
b. Better life style, home, family
V. Opportunity
a. Knowledge
b. Education
c. Jobs/Career
d. Financial Stability
e. Better Future
VI. Health
a. Limited Healthcare
VII. Future
a. Opportunities for children
b. Better future for children
i. Different lifestyle, education, job/career, healthcare, home, working members of society.
LikeLike
Thesis Statement:
Why do immigrants come to America? Immigrants come to America for a safe haven, education, jobs or career, opportunity, health, and for their children’s future.
LikeLike
Outline- Immigration
1{intro
A. Thesis- there should not be a huge wall sectioning off one country from other. There needs to be a better way to check peoples’ record instead of just building a wall. Not everyone who enters is a criminal.
B. Topic-immigration
C. point of view-anti-wall
2[Body First/reason/claim- people should be able to pursue their goal for a better life, even if it means immigrating. United States was founded by immigrates
3[Explain-the pros of immigration…great immigrants
4[example -arturo/alma…benny/esquala/
5[conclusion- immigration should be allowed
LikeLike
Outline
I. Introduction
a. Mayor was not wrong about lying to his dad about playing soccer because Mayor is being pushed to do something he does not want to do, he was compared too much to his brother, and his dad was putting the male Hispanic stereotype on him.
II. His dad was pushing him to do something he did not want to do
a. Mayor does not want to play soccer
b. He is not good at it
c. One day at practice Mayor pushes himself to practice, but fails
III. His dad imposes the Hispanic male stereotypes to him
a. His dad says the soccer is a panama sport
b. Does not tell his dad because he is scared he might get angry
c. Males are supposed to be the head of the house
IV. He was compared to his brother
a. Enrique is good at soccer and got a scholarship
b. Always in the news
c. Popular in high school
d. Grades were good
LikeLike
CONTINUED:
Thesis:
Bullying continues to spread through our society like a cancer and needs to be eradicated by any means necessary to preserve the mental and physical well-being of our youth.
LikeLike
I. (Intro) Just as my mother came to America to escape the harsh reality of her warring home country, we can see Maribel and family leaving everything to start a new life despite the rough road ahead.
A. State my view or side on the topic of immigration.
II. Barely coming over and starting a new life. Adjusting to the way of life, the American way. How this society works compared to the life they use to have back in their home country?
A. Interview my mother and see what life was like leaving everything she knew and everyone she loves to start fresh.
III. How they adjust and what they found difficult. Find evidence on how they been adjusting and see if my mom had the same problems understanding English language and see if she found a job right away and how she managed to make/ start her life over her without knowing anyone.
A. Find points in the book stating problems and how they resolved it.
IV. What makes immigration such a problematic stance and why is the problem the way it is and what can we do to fix it?
LikeLike
Thesis: The Riveras went so far as to leave everything they had behind in Mexico and move to a new country with hopes to provide a better life for their daughter.
I. Intro
a. Introduce theme of the paper. Focus on the extent parents will go for their children.
b. Thesis: The Riveras went so far as to leave everything they had behind in Mexico and move to a new country with hopes to provide a better life for their daughter.
II. Body paragraph #1
a. Describe Maribel’s accident
b. How this affected both of her parents (especially Alma)
c. Introduce their decision to travel to the United States in search of help for their daughter
III. Body paragraph #2
a. Discuss the struggles immigrants face when trying to get to America (scene in first couple of pages where they are crossing border in red truck)
b. Illegal crossing of the border/consequences (Research)
c. Process of obtaining a visa(Research)
IV. Body paragraph #3
a. How different life was once the Riveras actually got to America
b. Language Barrier
c. Expectations vs. Reality (House with a white picket fence vs. the cinder block house)
V. Conclusion
a. Summarize essay
b. Restate thesis: The Riveras went to the extreme of moving to a new country in an attempt to help their daughter.
c. Vaguely restate points of struggle for Maribel’s parents
LikeLike
Outline & Thesis
I. Intro
Thesis
Fear is prevalent throughout the text. It shows itself from Mayor living a lie, to Alma and others keeping secrets and not revealing the truth. The fear that is shown can be caused by their anxiety and in order for them to overcome it they should be able to have external help to relieve their worries, for example: counselors, or friends they trust.
II. Research fear and anxiety
Provide examples on how individuals have been able to overcome fear caused by peer pressure
Or fear caused by parental discipline
III. How different characters have shown their fear throughout the novel.
Find scenes that fit
IV. Personal experiences in dealing with similar situations
Interviewing family members
Getting their P.O.V on how we responded and how they compare to the decision making of holding back the truth.
V. Conclusion
It is always helpful to be able to rely on certain individuals or ways of having a “fire escape” when dealing with fear due to our circumstances or upbringing.
LikeLike
Outline for The book of unknown Americans essay.
Thesis: The language barrier of not speaking, reading and not understanding English can be a communication problem. The language barrier causes problems for the characters in the book.
I. Introduction
a) Impact of language barriers in communication.
b) From book page 7 (Alma explaining little to no English that they speak)
c) language barrier explanation/ is it hard to learn English
d) Example from book pages 9-11 (Arturo paying for groceries)
II. Body paragraph 1
a) What is language barrier (site source)?
b) Examples from book pages 27-29 (Alma)
c) Why the examples show that it is hard to communicate.
III. Body paragraph 2
a) Why is it hard to have a conversation?
b) Example from my understanding/ experience
c) Examples and explanations from book pages 49-51
d) Example from book Pages 58 and 59
IV. Body paragraph 3
a) Research about language barrier (source 1)
b) Why is it hard? reasons
c) What do non English speaking people have to do in order to learn English
d) Example from the book page 58 and 59 and 62-63 (difficulties learning English)
V. Body paragraph 4
a) Research about language barrier (source 2)
b) How to make learning English easier?
c) Reasons/ evidence
d) Examples from the book about how not knowing English can be dangerous pages 70-72. And why making English learned more easily is important.
VI. Conclusion
a) Summarize essay
b) Include the importance of how serious the problem is
c) Include how we can maybe help make learning English
d) Answer the so what question
LikeLike
Intro: introducing the book and my topic with a story from the book
Thesis: a relevant issue in our society is that mexicans have been targeted of being bad people since passed years just like in The Book of Unknown Americans.
Not all americans who come to the US are part of a gang or rapist.
Evidence from sources and book that back up my topic
Parts from the story that relate to racism
Conclusion
LikeLike
Outline
-Intro:
-As I read, “The book of Unknown Americans,” I noticed that Alma was a typical mother who cared for her daughter and husband though faced many hardships within their relationship due to her insecurities.
-Claim
Though she makes many mistakes and gets side tracked, Alma is a caring mother who needs to take responsibility towards her mistake and improve as a whole.
I. -First reason and Evidence
Almas shows many aspects of her being a loving mother and wanting to see her daughter succeed.
o “Maybe I would even learn enough to be able to help Maribel with her homework” (Henriquez 58).
She wants to be there for her daughter and even though she makes a mistake she shows how she regrets it and feels bad for leaving her daughter alone.
o “I didn’t even have the heart to ask whether she was sure because I didn’t want to give her the chance to take it back” (Henriquez 66).
II. Second reason and Evidence
Alma is a caring mother but she has made mistakes that she should own up to in order to help her daughter.
o “As I turned the corner, I saw her. Her back was against the wall, and her hands were up over her head … the boy from the gas station … was holding her wrists in place … her shirt was bunched under her armpits, exposing her white cotton bra… her eyes squeezed shut” (Henriquez 121).
After the incident one would expect Alma to tell Arturo about the assault that happened to Maribel though she doesn’t.
o “I had not told him what happened. I wasn’t going to tell him. I didn’t want him to know that I had failed Maribel again” (Henriquez 122).
III. Third reason and Evidence
Why do people lie? why does she make decisions like that towards protecting her daughter?
Even though the mom has so many issues this is only because within parenting styles you may face these issues.
In Almas case her reputation would be the perfect wife and mother and she lies because she feels guilty that she would lose that title.
o “Some people lie for reputation purposes” (Basu 1).
One must look at Almas parenting styles and why she lets her guilt over rule her decisions she makes and why she lies.
o “when unstable high self-esteem people experience failure, their underlying self-doubt is reflected in physiological responses” (Moudgil 169).
Conclusion: All in all, alma may face many self-esteem issues and might show that she makes decisions through guilt though she has shown that she is a good mother and can be there for her child. She moved all this way to provide Maribel with a better life.
Citation for source:
Basu, Tanya. “Why Do People Lie When They Can Easily Get Caught?” Time.Com, 18 Sept. 2015. EBSCOhost
Moudgil, Ranjana and Nandini Moudgil. “Parenting Styles and Self-Esteem as Predictors of Aggression.” Indian Journal of Health & Wellbeing, vol. 8, no. 2, Feb. 2017, pp. 168-172. EBSCOhost, chaffey.idm.oclc.org/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=122565565&site=ehost-live.
LikeLike
I. Family is an integral role to the plot of the book of unknown Americans. three characters in particular has been affected by their families sphere of influence the most. Maribel, Mayor, and garret. Thesis: Family shapes who we are as a person whether for better or for worse.
II. Maribel has a very protective mother and a loving father, her mothers actions caused Maribel to be in the current situation that she is in now.
III. Mayor has a very different relationship between all his family members, he has a piece of each of them within himself and it’s reflected in the story.
IV: Garret’s family seems to have affected him greatly and shaped the current character we see in the story. even though his family is only mentioned very little and are not currently present in the story, one line from garret hints as to what relationship he has with his father in particular.
V: Conclusion.
LikeLike
Thesis
Maribel and Mayor’s short-lived relationship is definitely the real deal. Love is a very complicated emotion, there is no wrong or right way and we all do it differently. Their relationship should not be under speculation, whichever way they expressed theirs should be accepted and respected.
Analysis Outline
Topic: “Can teenage love be real or is it just oxytocin talking?
Intro:
I. Remember what it felt like when you were a teen and in love for the first time? Did you get butterflies in your stomach every time that special someone came around? Do you often find yourself doodling him/her name on your notebook? Did you feel like it was the best feeling in the world and didn’t want it end? Well… so did Mayor and Maribel.
II. After reading The Book of Unknown Americans by Cristina Henriquez, I fell in love with Mayor and Maribel’s unique short-lived love story. How? Could anyone not. Not only did it bring back really good memories but it’s completely relatable to anyone that lived a normal teenage life and thought they were in love at some point.
Question: Should Maribel and Mayors relationship be considered as real love, infatuation or a combination?
Thesis: Maribel and Mayor’s short-lived relationship is definitely the real deal. Love is a very complicated emotion there is no wrong or right way and we all do it differently. Their relationship should not be under speculation, whichever way they expressed theirs should not be under speculation but accepted and respected.
Body:
I. Background info or definition of teenage love.
II. Background info on Maribel and Mayor.
III. Describe, quote and explain how their relationship developed, what happened during their relationship, explain why I think it’s real love with supported research from the book and outside sources.
Conclusion: Finishing argument with summary of the entire piece, clear answer to my question.
LikeLike
Mayor knows that she has some problems with her, but that doesn’t stop him from truly loving her. The real reason is that Maribel parents do not know how to cope with their love, if it is true.
1.Intro/thesis about love
2.whats going on with maribel and mayor
3.a story about about true love
4. compare the true love between TR and maribel and mayor
5.Conclusion about everything
LikeLike
Topics:
Teenage love (Is Mayor really in love with Maribel?)
Brain Injury (Maribel’s behavior before and after)
Bad decisions (Is it okay to lie or wait to tell the truth?)
Language (Should everyone learn a language they aren’t familiar with?)
Beauty (Is being beautiful get you in trouble?)
Racism (Why are we treated differently just because we come from somewhere else?)
Topic Chosen:
Overthinking (Do we over think to protect ourselves or others? Both?)
Intro:
We all should know the tale “The Boy Who Cried Wolf.” In a village, a boy was bored so he yelled wolf to get attention from villagers. He did this several times, but the villagers had enough and decided not to listen to him if he did cry wolf the next time. This time, however, the boy cried wolf because there really was a wolf that was going to eat him. The villagers didn’t listen and the boy was eaten. Was it a bad decision for the boy to do that in the first place or were the villagers at fault in this situation? Lying causes someone to lose certain things, such as trust. If lying revolves around someone, there is a high possibility that they won’t have friends to talk to. Drama is caused from someone that lied about a certain topic just so they can gain popularity or something of that sort. But why do we lie? Is it to protect ourselves or to protect others? Is it good or is it bad? In “The Book of Unknown Americans,” the character Alma has been seen as a protagonist, but throughout the book, she has always overthought certain things and kept secrets from her husband and other people in the story. I believe that Alma, as a parent, lied in order to protect those around her. She accused herself to be the problem for everything, yet the audience wouldn’t think so. Lying causes others to believe that was apart of something
II. First supporting reason: Overthinking inflicts decisions or actions.
Evidence: Alma believed that Arturo didn’t trust her when it came down to Maribel. She also assumed that he blamed her for Maribel’s accident.
Evidence: Alma told herself to not tell Arturo what happened to Maribel when Garrett sexually assaulted her. Why did she do that? Because she didn’t want him to blame her again, even though Arturo never did in the first place.
III. Next supporting reason: Lying puts you in a bad position than you could have been in if you didn’t lie in the first place.
Evidence: Mayor lied about playing soccer, even though he wasn’t playing anymore. He thought that his dad would kill him and be disappointed in him for not being like his older brother.
Evidence: Use Alma again
IV. Conclusion: Lying puts anything at risk, but it also has positive and negative outcomes. Telling little white lies, in certain situations wouldn’t necessarily hurt anybody at first, but might in the future. In most situations, lying would be considered optional, but if the person thinks more in depth about it, they could get away with it.
LikeLike
Bullying
1. Intro
a. Bullying argument between Garret and Mayor.
b. Thesis, “Their behavior has negative consequence and regrets, also it relates to my proposal when I was in middle school and high school.”
II. Body Paragraph
a. Garret crowed up behind her, settling his hands on her lips. drawing her against him.
b. It was sexual harassment and bulling
III. Body Paragraph
a. Garrett was bullying Mayor and Maribel.
b. Person stands up against him
IV. Body Paragraph
a. He was cuss on him
b. I found it was bullying
LikeLike
The are many people who struggle with starting a new career, moving to a new home, or even starting a new school you have to learn to adjust to it in order to be comfortable with it but here in the novel ‘The book of Unknown Americans” most of the characters come to America making it their new home because either of their families or because they felt that it was better opportunities for them. In the Novel Ceila Toro feels that if they go back to Panama it will still be the same but her husband Rafael is convinced that everything has changed.
LikeLike
I. Toro family move to their family because of the revelation that was going on.
a. Ceila wanted to go back home because of her sister and that it would still be the same.
b. Rafael felt that if he would go back it would be the same and he got conformation from that when he was getting ready to go back to the Panama to visit for his class reunion.
II. The oldest son Enrique goes back home to visit his family during Christmas and feels that everything was strict and that there are better things out there when he is talking to his brother Mayor.
a. Mayor being rebellious towards his family is a way of him not following the rules and going against what his family want for him.
III. The River family coming to the U.S for their daughter.
IV. Neila coming to America because of the American dream.
LikeLike
Check out the Beast and the Beuty
LikeLike