Locate an article, news report, or social media post to respond to. You can also respond to any of the articles or topics discussed in the class.
First, summarize what the post is saying and what you understand them to be arguing.
Second, respond to the article with what we have been learning in class.
- Point out fallacies if you see them.
- Evaluate the argument they are making.
- Explain any bias you see in the post.
- Point out unsupported claims.
- If you agree, help them better support their argument. If you disagree, explain why.
Make sure your journal response is at least 250 words long. Comment below with a link and your response.
Kim Kardashian West and her family have been a controversial topic for a while now through most social media and tabloids. The body image the women of the Kardashian- Jenner family flaunt is a very unrealistic one for not only their fans, but for all women and men who believe these body images to be natural and very achievable, when in fact they are not. What the Kardashian- Jenner women do is flaunt their slim to almost no waist, plump bottoms, hefty cleavage, and shiny tans, as well as their perfectly, flawless, contoured faces. Not only is the flaunting of their unrealistic body goals hindering to women, but it is a marketing strategy for them as well. In a world where women are already hyper sexualized and overexposed, these women use their bodies to sell their products and launch new products. The way in which they go about business is by joining the long line of men that for years have been hyper sexualizing women because ‘sex sells.’ Not only do these women make other women bodily conscious, but they set us back as well. How are women supposed to be taken seriously in the workplace when women like this make it harder for others to be taken in a serious, professional manner capable of bringing more to the table than just their bodies. Kim Kardashian West is currently studying to be a lawyer, and it is possible for a woman to be a woman and a professional, but there is a limit and Kim Kardashian does not realize that. How are people supposed to separate a woman from her profession if she can not do that herself? What I mean by this is, yes, it is possible for a woman to be attractive and flaunt it, but when that is the only thing they rely on it becomes hard to differentiate that persona from her professional persona. And that is why the Kardashian- Jenner family sets women back decades after so much in the movement for equality, which includes taking women more seriously in the workplace. The women of the Kardashian- Jenner women argue that they can be both attractive body flaunting women and savvy professional businesswomen, but how can that be when all they promote are their own personal products that are to be sold off of their own hyper sexual exploitation.
LikeLike
Maria L. Navarro
November, 17, 2019
Emma Coronel Aispuro makes classy debut on VH1s Cartel Crew Reality Show
Who is Emma Coronel Aispuro ? she is a Mexican, American women marriage with Joaquin Guzman Loera (El Chapo Guzman). During their time together, Emma has had two children with Joaquin. The better half of the convicted drug kingpin is joining the cast of cartel crew. The show follows the lives of families born into the South American narcotics business as they try to live their ties to the game in the past. For the most part the storylines focus on each member trying to live a civilian life while attempting to monopolize on their legacy.
According to the network Emma “opens up about her life after El Chapo and her upcoming business venture”which is most likely the clothing brand launched in his likeness. You can watch a teaser with her introduction to Cartel Crew below.
Emma Coronel started her business with clothing brand named the Chapo trademark.
I choose this article because is interesting that Emma Coronel is going to exposure her life in a reality show. The first day was on Monday November,11, 2019. She meets with Ramirez Arellano and her boyfriend Michael Corleone Blanco the youngest son, one of the members of the Medellin Cartel in Colombia. “ She is a real Latina, a real humble person, loyal to her man,” Ramirez Arellano said.
LikeLike
Campaign for needs because “poverty is common in African countries, children are at risk for hunger, HIV, AIDs and diseases, and therefore people should donate money to help people of Africa,” is what we often seen and hear through social media and on the television everyday. Is this really true? Why do they conclude that donation will solve African problems? Why has the problem not solved with all the donations they have been receiving from decades?
Many charity organizations around the world had been collecting money and materials things to help Africa country overcome poverty for several decades. Millions of people world-wide have contributed money and resources to charity organizations and foundations; some are still contributing everyday even up till today. Majority of the people that are donating money to charity to help Africa countries are doing so because they pity people of Africa, due to the negative pictures and fake news shared on social media everyday about Africa countries. If all the money that people are donating is actually going to poor people in Africa, then, all African should have become rich by now. The question is, why is Africa countries still remain poor base on the images of poor children we see every day on social media, despite the trillions of dollars donating to Africa countries every month across the world?. Many people are becoming a victim because they think Africa people are all living in poverty, starvation, HIV, and chronic sicknesses, because they did not realize the fact that Africa countries are rich with minerals resources and talented people. Charity organizations are also ignorance that the government and the leaders of Africa countries they are giving the money to, to share, are corrupt and greedy and they are the real problem that Africa countries have. Many fundraiser and charity organization are generating the money to pay their own salaries and their workers’ salaries, the rest of the money as well did not get to the hand of the poor people they claimed they are helping. The material things as well they collected like toys, clothes, shoes and other materials things are been taken to Africa for sell as fairly used materials instead of giving them to poor people. It is unfair for organization to be using negative image to portray other people for their own gain. Most people in Africa , if not all, are not aware that some people are donating money or material things for them at all. So, whoever wants to donate money to Africa poor people should travel to Africa and see for themselves, and hand the money to the hand of the poor people they see, instead of listening to fake images, news and negative commercial on the television portraying Africa as a poor continent.
https://www.compassion.com/donate/donate-to-children-in-africa.htm?
https://www.globaljustice.org.uk/myth-6-africa-needs-our-help
LikeLike
https://twitter.com/YGTrece21_/status/1196015117613371394?s=20
This tweet is by a person who believes that all women are disloyal to their partners. He states that there aren’t any women in his generation that are loyal. He goes on to say that women sleep with lots of other people, they are untrustworthy, or they are single mothers. There is so much to unpack just from this 279-character tweet. The logical fallacy this person uses is called a hasty generalization. Hasty generalizations are when people jump to conclusions, which leads to stereotyping and exaggerated arguments. This person is arguing that all women in his generation are disloyal, untrustworthy, promiscuous, and come with too much baggage. The bias is clear in this tweet. Without prior experience in dating and being cheated on by women, it would be difficult to jump to this conclusion. This person may have been cheated on by a few different women. There is also a lack of support for his claims. There is no evidence present, just arguments being made. I do not agree with the argument in this tweet. There is absolutely no way that anyone could ever know if every woman is unfaithful to their partners. This argument also makes it seem as though it is bad for women to have a lot of different sexual partners, and that it is bad to date a woman that already has a kid. I do not agree with these assumptions because of the lack of evidence, as well as the difference in our morals.
LikeLike
This article is about plastic surgery. It argues the 4 reasons why someone should never get surgery. The first reason is because its pricey, obviously. American Academy of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery stated that in 2016, Americans spent over 7 billion dollars in surgical procedures and 5 billion on non-surgical procedures.The second reason is because it is addictive. I liked how they included an example of a person named Cindy Jackson who broke the world record for having the most procedures done. Another reason is because it is a risky business. They claim that breast implants can have multiple complications. Something that I suggest they could have done here was add statistics of how many complications were reported throughout the years that way it can make their claim stronger. The last reason is that people might be unhappy with the results. They did give a bit of evidence that supports their claim, which is a study by the Aesthetic Surgery Institute that had a count of patients who were unhappy. You can obviously tell that they don’t support plastic surgery, so by showing people the reasons not to do it can make them think twice about their decision. Some points that they made can use more evidence to make it stronger.
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/cons-of-plastic-surgery_n_5618623
LikeLike
Fallacies, as we were informed in class, are mistaken beliefs or misconceptions which renders an argument worthless.
In the tweet/photo above a young lady was made a reply to an article based on gun violence. In the article and Oklahoma congressman made an outrageous claim that video games and lack of Jesus in Florida.
The claim made by the congressman can be considered a logical fallacy. video games don’t put weapons (guns) in the hands of children neither do they make kids want to hurt each other. Also, as much as the presence of Jesus may be necessary for the lives of today’s youths that doesn’t imply less gun violence either.
Furthermore, as much as the young lady’s reply happened to hold much thought, it still a fallacy. She referred to the Australian gun control legislation and claimed that if the United States Adopted this legislation, there will be less gun violence.
At first glance, this seems to be a worthy opinion or choice of action but it’s not. The fact that the Australian Gun Violence Legislation produced good results in Australia that doesn’t mean it will be effective in the United States. This is because both nations are different. Their legislation, their constitutions, their way of life, their culture, the number of guns in circulation and so on. In other words, the argument becomes useless.
LikeLike
http://theantisense.com/2018/11/13/true-story-i-injected-myself-with-a-crispr-genetic-enhancement/
Dr. Josiah Zayner is a biophysicist and former NASA employee who worked on designing habitats for use in space colonization. He is now a biohacker. In the article, he describes his journey from academia, to NASA, and how his experiences led him to reject the current formal pardigm of science to pursue a more radical approach to genetic engineering. Biohackers are the wet and sloppy version of computer hackers, with similar ideologies: large, well funded entities should not have sole control and access to technology for it would give them absolute power; access to the technology should therefore be available to everyone. So what biohackers do is basically hack the genetic code in their garages with CRISPRCas9. CRISPR stand for Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats. Dr. Zayner started a crowdfunding campaign to bring the CRISPR technology to the public, and succeeded in raising 70,000 to start-up the business of selling gene-editing kits.
The first portion of the article is what I will analyze in which Josiah seeks to explain and justify his movement away from formal science and into his controversial exploits in gene editing. His description of working at the NASA Ames Research Center in mountain View involves calling out the bureaucratic and political “bullshit” that got in the way of conducting actual meaningful work. Here is the heart of his argument, that large established organizations are not conducive to innovation, nor will they benefit the public. This describes the character of the Establishment, and therefore the character of its antithesis the biohackers. Dr. Zayner makes no attempt to hide his bias against the old-guard of science who he describes as being set in their ways and inflexible to change. Although he makes his position clear, Dr. Zayner fails to point out the dangers of making gene-editing technology to everyone. This, however, is part of his ethos, that the benefits outweigh the risks. Regardless of the ethics of biohacking, Dr. Zayner intends on continuing his work.
LikeLike
In this Instagram post from Actress Rosario Dawson, she is shown pictured with the text “#NotInvisible”. The Actress lets you know in her Instagram post that 84 percent of Native American women are suffering and that it is important for us to raise awareness and show that these women are not alone and something must be done. I found this image extremely simply but even more impactful. Although there was no complete story being told to the reader, the author uses pathos by appealing to the emotions, and logos to hook the audience with statistics, and lastly she also uses ethos by using her social platform as an entertainer to gain the reader’s trust. It worked because I further researched this issue and was shocked at the numbers. The National Institute of Justice conducted a study in 2016 and found more than 1.5 million Native American women have endured cruelty and brutality in their lifetime. That is 84 percent. Of that 84 percent more than half of these women suffer as victims of domestic or sexual abuse. Additionally, this research concluded that Ninety-seven percent of the offenders are non-tribal members or non-Native. Since the Native American people are governed under their own laws, the offenders cannot be prosecuted in tribal courts because they do not have jurisdiction to do so. Using social media as a platform to shed light on this issue is a great idea. The author appeals to the reader’s emotions. I with the text and the subtext of this image; it is powerful. Also, the author uses this image as an extreme example of “Waving the Bloody Shirt” fallacy to stress that no matter how questionable you may think this is because you have not heard about it, the issue cannot be questioned without dishonoring the blood of those who dies. This post also uses “The Free Speech” fallacy. Social media is used as a “Safe Place” to voice your opinion or tell your story and it is frowned upon if you do not respect people who stand in solidarity due to personal experience or morals.
LikeLike
El Chapos wife Emma Coronel appears on VH1 show Cartel Crew, there has been a lot of controversy around this topic mostly because people feel that they are trying to glorify the drug dealers lifestyle which is a bias opinion because she is being judged based on what her husband did. She is in the show to show a side we don’t know to where she is legally creating a merch business because after all she is a regular person like any of us who just happens to be married to a former drug dealer. The fallacy here is false speculations and opinions on someone we know little to nothing of based on who she’s married to which is misleading. i don’t agree with the argument being made here because the show is about showcasing their life not their spouses/parents who were the ones involved in criminal activities and they shouldn’t be judged because of that. she is a mother/wife and many of us can relate to these roles and after all she needs to provide for her daughters and she is doing it legally so why knock her down without a fair chance.
https://nypost.com/2019/11/16/el-chapos-wife-emma-coronel-aispuro-makes-classy-debut-on-on-vh1s-cartel-crew/
LikeLike
As learned in class, Fallacies are faulty reasoning or mistaken believes. The original tweet by LIV shows fallacy because “niggas” do want money fr(the quoted tweet is for entertainment purposes).LIV has a mistaken believe because me and people I know prove otherwise. Not only do we talk about wanting money, we are actively working towards acquiring more money. I currently have a Job, which I have aspirations to move up within. Im also going to school to get a higher paying job, all the while investing into mutual stocks and learning the Forex trade. A fellow named Jake has a job, is in school for the same reason as me, and has a taking off Beef Jerky business. Another man, Tim, has a job and is in school, but unlike jake, he has two businesses. These are all factual examples that prove against LIV’s believe, making it a fallacy.
LikeLike