Due
Post your Literary Analysis today. Hand in your rough draft or email it.
Casso “Worth the Lie”
Take 10-15 minutes to review the article. Work in groups of 2 or 3. Winner will get a reward.
What is Casso’s argument?
How does Casso support the argument he is making? Find examples of ethos, pathos, and logos.
Notes:
- Sort of cost-benefit analysis
- Measuring praise and blame
- Making the weaker argument the stronger one, playing devil’s advocate
Argument or Persuasion?
For the final assignment I am working on developing a better assignment. I don’t want you to just go through the motions of argumentation. I want you to do good in the world. I have three approaches I am thinking about.
- Pick a side you want to argue on your topic of choice.
- Persuade us of something you know that we don’t. Do some good in the world.
- Argue for a cause you believe in.
Example for the second choice.
Faith healers are not doctors. If you have a serious condition, you should seek out trained medical professionals. REAL doctors that can help you. A faith healer is someone who performs “faith healing” which is usually a trick. They might do psychic surgery and “remove” the cancer, but in actuality do nothing but take your money. Don’t go to a healer, go to a doctor for science based medicine.
“I Have a Dream” Speech
Martin Luther King Jr. gave one of the best speeches in history. How does he develop his ethos? How does he use appeals to emotion and logic to get us to see his perspective. How does he persuade us to see the truth he knows?
Write down some examples of ethos, logos, and pathos from the speech.
Write
What do Casso’s argument and Dr. King’s argument have in common? What can we learn from them to apply to our argument paper?
Ethos: Lance Armstrong for credibility (page 70), ESPN Brian Triplett (page 71), (page 71) Countless stories of cancer victims expressing gratitude toward Armstrong. Armstrong diagnosed with testicular cancer over came all odds to become the greatest cyclist of all time. Armstrong used the money he made to give back to the community.
Pathos: (page 71) sentence starting in … I was wondering if and ending in … cancer!) (page 74) Middle paragraph!
Logos: (page 73) paragraph begging with ( in 2007, USA today ranked Lance Armstrong as ….)
LikeLike
Casso’s argument is that Lance Armstrong’s lies were in the end justified because he provided so much inspiration to people with cancer as well as gave so much money from his foundation developed from his fame. His doping enabled him to succeed as well as he did and if he had admitted to the drugs earlier in his career his impact would be much less. Casso argues that the end justified the mean.
LikeLike
Pathos page 72: quote from celou ” I am a cancer survivor and you were giving me courage when i needed it most… my hero forever”
Ethos page 71: Casso makes a personal connection with Armstrong story because both of them struggle with cancer.
Logos page 75: In the early 1900s Rockerfeller, owner of Standard Oil, was among the most hated entrepreneurs in America…then became the richest man in America for business.
LikeLike
Cassos argument is you may find courage for your own situation through someone else’s experience.
the ethos of this argument is that they use a credible person such as lance armstrong. a true actual cancer survivor. The logos of the argument was that just because you you are fighting somthing as deadly as cancer does not mean you are completely destined for death. the pathos of this argument is that the emotional appeal in this argument
LikeLike
Ethos- listing all of Arnold Armstrong’s accomplishments. How he is a well know cancer survivor that on to win the tour de france despite any setbacks he may have encountered with being a cancer survivor.
Pathos- Strips away his credibility by stating that Arnold was using illegal supplements to help him with his training and went on about it all wrong.
Logos- Explains and supports his claims of had Arnold admitted he was using supplements his level of fame wouldn’t have reached the level it did. His outcome would have been a lot different and people wouldn’t see him as the hero they thought he was.
LikeLike
Pathos: Barbara has cancer and no family, Armstrong is her idol. writes a letter to him.
Ethos: Browsed through articles to find other people who admired Armstrong, Casso also admired Armstrong.
Logos: Despite Armstrong using performing enhancing drugs, he became an inspiring well known public figure and used his platform to bring cancer awareness and started the Livestrong Foundation that accumulated $36 mil for cancer research.
LikeLike
1.)He is arguing that just because someone makes a mistake that doesn’t make them a bad person. You have to look passed that and actually see all the good that Lance Armstrong did like his donations and his inspiration that he spread throughout people not just cancer patients but everyone. Not just with Armstrong but with anyone, there’s good and bad in everyone, dont judge someone off of just the bad they’ve done.
“Despite his lies (or maybe because of them), Lance Armstrong saved lives through his work with the Livestrong Foundation…”
LikeLike
Casso’s argument is that Lance Armstrong’s use of enhancement performance drugs was justified.
Ethos= eventhough Lance lied, he encouraged other people that are fighting cancer.
Logos=Page 73 In 2007, Usa today ranked Lance Armstrong
Pathos= Casso’s touched the lives of many people.
LikeLike