We all must have read the fable The Boy Who Cried Wolf when we were children. A shepherd boy is bored from watching the village sheep, so he cries wolf to seek attention from the villagers. Of course, the villagers drop everything and get to the boy, only to find him laughing at them. He tricked the villagers a second time into thinking that there was a real wolf, but the third time he cried wolf, he was being serious about seeing a wolf, which was prowling the sheep, yet the villagers didn’t listen to the shepherd boy, which caused the sheep to be startled by the wolf and ran away from the village. This story had a lesson behind it, which is that no one will believe a liar when they tell the truth, but why do we still manage to lie? Is it to protect ourselves or to protect others? Is it good to lie or is it bad? In “The Book of Unknown Americans,” the character Alma and Mayor are seen as protagonists, but throughout the book, both have over thought certain situations and kept secrets from several characters in the story. I believe that lying isn’t the best decision, even when others may think it isn’t to an extent. A liar won’t ever be acknowledged, there will always be consequences from lying, and people will lie to benefit others.

As children are parents more than likely lied to us. Lying intended to benefit others is referred to as prosocial lying. According to the authors of Lying because we care: Compassion increases prosocial lying, the authors state “Prosocial lying is socialized in early life; parents lie to their children to promote positive emotions, and children, in turn, understand and tell prosocial lies themselves” (Lupoli, et al). Parents would tell their children lies to make them happy, such as the Tooth Fairy, Santa Claus, etc. Alma in The Book of Unknown Americans portrays a prosocial liar. “I didn’t want him to know that I had failed Maribel again” (Henriquez 122). Alma felt that she shouldn’t tell her husband, Arturo, that she found her daughter, Maribel, who was assaulted by Garrett, a boy who had an interest in Maribel, but his intentions were far below good. Why wouldn’t she tell her own husband that their daughter was assaulted? Garrett wouldn’t be a problem if Alma took action. She comes to this state of mind that she can’t tell Arturo what happened because she thinks that Arturo was upset with her when Maribel had the accident. Alma assumes that her husband is still mad at her for Maribel’s accident, even though she never made the effort into asking him if he saw her to blame.

Lying has its consequences. Mayor, the son of Rafael and Celia Toro, was in soccer, but he embarrassed himself so harshly that to prevent it from happening again, he quit the team, yet lied to his parents that he was still attending soccer practice. “And I struggled to nod through the rush of guilt I felt about lying to him and the humiliation I felt about sucking so bad” (Henriquez 68). Mayor’s lie, however, led to bad consequences. “I thought you were out there, every day, playing, part of the team. But what have you been doing instead? Drugs? Drinking?” (Henriquez 131). As a parent, lying is the last thing they’d want their children to do. The idea of not knowing where their child is most of the time or what they are doing is extremely terrifying. The audience is well aware from that moment on in the book, Mayor wouldn’t be trusted again after lying.

The majority of people would admit that they lied in order to benefit others. Hell, we have all been in that situation, especially to make the others happy. When I was a child, I had a dog, named Shrek, in which we had since I was maybe about three years old. I distinctly remember my parents informing me that my companion was sick, so he was located at our local veterinarian’s office. For a while, I’d consistently asked my parents when he’ll come home. “Soon” they’d say to me. As time passed on, I eventually forgot about him. Now that I’m older, I knew that he passed away. My parents lied in order to protect me from my emotions. I for one am an extremely emotional person, so their lie in this scenario was positive. In Mayor’s case, he lied to his father because he knew that his father wanted him to be just like his older brother. A young and successful student. Mayor lied in order to please his father for acceptance, but he, unfortunately, didn’t get away from the lie. According to the article, the authors state “When faced with the opportunity to tell a prosocial lie, two prosocial ethics are pitted against one another. Individuals must either lie to reduce harm or provide care to another or tell the truth, which could also provide benefits for the target. Thus far, it is unclear how compassion influences behavior in moral dilemmas when different prosocial values are in conflict” (Lupoli, et al). A person comes to a point in their state of mind when choosing whether to lie because of assumed consequences. Would it be a good decision, to tell the truth, or lie to reduce harm to another?

Lying is a neutral choice when it comes down to making the decision to do so or not, but we are very well aware that lying has its consequences, whether it is beneficial or not. It’s safe to say that lying is the best choice depending on the given situation or scenario. But the source of lying is overthinking. People tend to overthink, creating the outcomes of an action they took part in, seeking further into their thoughts to see if they should lie about it in order to benefit others. If overthinking is the purpose for lying, what should be done to exclude it? Or is our actions more at fault in certain situations?

Works Cited

Henriquez, Cristina. The Book of Unknown Americans. Knopf, 2015.

Lupoli, Matthew J., et al. “Lying Because We Care: Compassion Increases Prosocial Lying.” Journal of Experimental Psychology. General, vol. 146, no. 7, July 2017, pp. 1026–1042. Academic Search Complete, EBSCOhost, doi:10.1037/xge0000315. Accessed 22 Sept. 2017.