
In May 1992, a 12-year-old girl gave a speech at the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro. That girl was Severn Cullis Suzuki, who would later go on to become known as, “The Girl Who Silenced the World for 5 Minutes”. Throughout her speech, Suzuki uses a variety of rhetorical devices and appeals in order to achieve her goal of spreading awareness of the environment’s deterioration, persuading the audience to learn about the effect of humans on the environment and consider how they can contribute to keeping the planet safe.
The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, also known as the Earth Summit, was a meeting between world leaders in order to “rethink economic development and find ways to halt the destruction of irreplaceable natural resources and pollution of the planet” (Earth_Summit). It was attended by 172 governments, 108 of which were on the level of heads of state or government, as well as 2,400 representatives from non-governmental organizations. In 1989, Suzuki, along with a group of her friends, formed the Environmental Children’s Organization (ECO) dedicated to teaching others about environmental issues. In 1992, they raised money to attend Rio’s Earth Summit. Along with three of her friends, Suzuki presented environmental issues through the eyes of a minor to an assembly of delegates. Even though she was only 12 years old at the time, it was expected that she uses formal tone and language. While her speech was given to the people attending the conference, she wanted to spread her message to people around the world.
Suzuki begins the speech by introducing her group and their reason for attending the conference. She reveals that she is, “speaking for “ECO” — the Environmental Children’s Organization. We are a group of 12 and 13 year-olds trying to make a difference: Vanessa Suttie, Morgan Geisler, Michelle Quigg, and me. We’ve raised all the money to come here ourselves — to come 5,000 miles to tell you adults you must change your ways”, which helps establish her ethos. At that age, children should not have to worry that much about the future of the world, because that’s what the adults are supposed to do. Yet, Suzuki and her organization raised money and came all the way from Canada just to attend this conference. To tell the adults what she thinks they should be doing, even though it should be the opposite. She clarifies that she has no ulterior motive, that this speech is purely to promote her goal of bringing change to the world. Unlike those present at the conference, she does not have any political or economic obligations to fulfill. Even if she did, to her “Losing my future is not like losing an election, or a few points on the stock market”. People should not sacrifice the future of others in order to achieve political, economic, or personal gains.
Throughout the speech, Suzuki uses imagery to explain the situation and appeal to the audience’s emotions. The environment is described as a place where she sees “countless animals dying” and “holes in our ozone”. She mourns the loss of “animals now extinct”, the salmon in the dead stream, and “the forests that once grew where there is now a desert”. Suzuki had once dreamt of seeing the rainforests, jungles, the wild plants and animals that lived there, of showing them to her children, yet in the current situation, those ecosystems may not even last that long. No one would want to hear all these negative descriptions. Suzuki hoped that hearing about the Earth’s condition would inspire people to take action.
According to Michael L. McKinney, urban development is one of the largest contributors to local extinction rates and the loss of native species. It also causes a reduction in the regional biodiversity, the “ biological uniqueness of local ecosystems”. These effects tend to last longer than with other causes of habitat loss (McKinney). In addition, Oscar Venter writes that “Habitat loss, affecting 84% of species, is the greatest threat to endangered species in Canada. Introduced species (22%), overexploitation (32%), pollution (26%), native species interactions (31%), and natural causes (27%) all affect much smaller proportions of species.” (Venter). Humans continue to urbanize without considering the negative effects it will have on the society and the environment. If this continues, many of the Earth’s natural habitats may permanently disappear.
Suzuki draws on personal anecdotes as she tells the story of how she used to go fishing at her home with her dad and how they soon found out that many of the fish were cancerous. In a 2001 report by the Canadian government, “The consumption of mercury contaminated fish is one of the main pathways for mercury exposure in humans, and may pose serious health risks, particularly for young children and the developing fetus.” (Government of Canada) The majority of the mercury released into the environment is a result of human activity, such as mining, electricity generation, and incineration. Not only does the mercury damage the environment and its inhabitants, it has the potential to harm humans as well. While there have been programs to help reduce the emission of mercury, mercury poisoning is still a large concern for many species of fish.
Suzuki directly asks her audience if they had to worry about these issues when they were children. She says, “All this is happening before our eyes and yet we act as if we have all the time we want and all the solutions. I’m only a child and I don’t have all the solutions. I don’t — I want you to realize, neither do you.” She wants people to stop acting like everything is ok, that they have everything figured out. Because in reality, they don’t. Her use of anaphora emphasizes her point as she repeats the words, “You don’t know how to” with a list of impossible tasks. There is no way these issues can be fixed, which is why she pleads, “If you don’t know how to fix it, please stop breaking it.” Even though we can’t save what has already been lost, we should at least try to preserve what we still have.
Suzuki then goes on to claim that “In Canada, we live the privileged life. We have plenty of food, water, and shelter. We have watches, bicycles, computers, and television sets. The list could go on for two days.”. While two days is obviously an exaggeration, it brings awareness to the difference in resources between those in first world countries to those who are not. She recounts the words of the children she had met in Brazil, who told her that if they had the money and resources, they would want to provide food, clothing, medicine shelter and love to everyone. She asks “If a child on the streets who has nothing is willing to share, why are we who have everything still so greedy?” This question is rhetorical, but she wants the audience to realize that even though a person has these privileges, they should still be aware of what else is happening in the world and do all they can to help.
In a broader sense, her speech is not just about the environment; it is about the way people react to issues. She reminds her audience that people are taught in school, as young as in kindergarten, how to act. We are taught not to fight with others, to respect others, to clean up after ourselves, to share, to be caring, among others. Adults are supposed to set a good example for children to follow, yet they go do the exact things they tell us not to do. How can they expect us to follow the rules when they themselves break them? Suzuki had believed that “Parents should be able to comfort their children by saying, “Everything’s going to be all right; it’s not the end of the world, and we’re — and we’re doing the best we can.”, yet she quotes her father, who had said “You are what you do, not what you say. ” She uses pathos as she states “Well, what you [adults] do makes me cry at night. You grown-ups say you love us.” The statement draws on the audience’s emotions, as the audience realizes the effect their actions may have on children. In a call to action, she asks them to “please, make your actions reflect your words.” It is not enough for one to say they will do something; their actions must follow through.
She claims that together, we are a family; everyone on this Earth is just one big family, and no border or government can deny that. It doesn’t matter if the people present are politicians, reporters, government officials or businesspeople; Suzuki uses pathos and logos, as she reasons, “you are mothers and fathers, sisters and brothers, aunts and uncles — and all of you are someone’s child.” She speaks for everyone, from now and for generations to come. We all live on this Earth so we should all work together to maintain it and protect it from further damage.
Annotated Bibliography
Cullis-Suzuki, Severn. “An Appeal for Future Generations.” Earth Island Journal, vol. 9, no. 2,
Spring94, p. 41. EBSCOhost
This is the full text of Severn Cullis-Suzuki’s speech at the United Nations Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992. It was published in the Earth Island Journal, which is a publication of Earth Island Institute.
“Earth_Summit.” United Nations, United Nations, http://www.un.org/geninfo/bp/enviro.html.
This source describes the United Nations Earth Summit that Suzuki spoke at and gives a summary of what happened. It describes who was present, what was discussed and what was achieved. While Suzuki herself is not mentioned in this summary, this became my reference as I analyzed the audience, occasion, and constraints. This is a reliable source because it is directly from the United Nations website.
Government of Canada, Environment and Climate Change Canada. “Environment and Climate
Change Canada – Pollution and Waste – Fish Consumption Advisories.” Government of
Canada, Environment and Climate Change Canada, 9 July 2013, ec.gc.ca/mercure-mercury/default.asp?lang=En&n=DCBE5083-97AD-4C62-8862.
This source provides information regarding fish consumption advisories related to mercury contamination in Canada. I was able to use this to describe the potential causes and effects of mercury contamination. The website also provided links to various regions across Canada. This is a valid source as it is from the Canadian government’s website and provides the results of their research.
McKinney, Michael L.“Urbanization, Biodiversity, and Conservation.” OUP Academic, Oxford
University Press, 1 Oct. 2002, academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/52/10/883-890/354714.
In this article, Michael McKinney describes the effects of urbanization across the urban-rural gradient. He includes information on biodiversity changes as well as compositional changes. I used this to describe the consequences of urban development on the environment. I would say this is a reliable source, as this was posted by Oxford University Press, which is a department at Oxford University.
Venter, Oscar, et al. “Threats to Endangered Species in Canada.” OUP Academic, Oxford
University Press, 1 Nov. 2006, academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/56/11/903/272301.
This article describes the various threats to endangered species in Canada, including threats by habitat type and the causes of these threats. It also includes comparisons to the United States as well as the world. This information was useful as I was able to connect it with the previous article about urban development. I would say this is a reliable source, as this was posted by Oxford University Press, which is a department at Oxford University.
I think on this essay, I deserve at least a B, as I was able to meet the basic requirements. I don’t think I did particularly outstanding in them, but I think I was able to interpret what her purpose was and how she tried to persuade the audience. Most of my sources came from reliable websites; those did not came from organizations with positive a reputation. I do think I could have done better on clarity, as I usually have trouble putting my thoughts on paper.
LikeLike