Locate an article, news report, or social media post to respond to. You can also respond to any of the articles or topics discussed in the class.
First, summarize what the post is saying and what you understand them to be arguing.
Second, respond to the article with what we have been learning in class.
- Point out fallacies if you see them.
- Evaluate the argument they are making.
- Explain any bias you see in the post.
- Point out unsupported claims.
- If you agree, help them better support their argument. If you disagree, explain why.
Make sure your journal response is at least 250 words long. Comment below with a link and your response.
https://forex-station.com/download/file.php?id=3336777&mode=view
If the meaning of this image is not clear, then the image displays a man chasing a wad of cash into his own grave. This speaks volume on not only American society, but societies around the world. Money is one of the most influential materials in the world, and can motivate people to do just about anything. When you really think about it, the value of money is so high, that a large majority of us get up and do things we do not want to just for the money. People work jobs to get money to use and spend and go to school just so they can eventually get a job and earn more money. Growing up, the dream job of most kids changes from being something fun, to being something that will get them the most money, and as those kids become adults, dreams change into reality, and earning money becomes an important factor. People start to put money over their own happiness and chase that cash until they die. Since you can never have too much money, people chase after it their whole lives, but at the end of the day, money does not mean much when you are already dead. Because society puts so many things that people want with a price tag, it is hard to blame people for chasing for that endless amount of money. Although living your whole life based off solely money can be depressing, money is quite necessary. Basic necessities like food and water come at a cost, even though they are absolutely needed for survival and have no other alternatives. Since there is a price tag placed on just about everything, it becomes quite hard to enjoy life without money, and furthermore even just survive without it. But what people in society tend to do, as this picture implies, is chase it into their own grave.
LikeLike
I chose a video that has to do with the famous preacher Benny Hen and his staged methods of “miracles”. In this video, it talks about how Benny Hen was exposed, when people would go to his famous crusades in search of a miracle or some type of healing that supposedly he could offer. He would preach to people that they were going to be healed but it turns out that it was all a lie. He would remove or try to detour the people who were severely disabled to a different location within the building and the people who were not as severe he would allow them to come forth as long as they would claim that they got a miracle from him.
This man was portraying something he was not. He was portraying miracles that were not happening. On his shows with just a touch of his hand or a stomp of his foot or even a blow from his lips, you would be healed but there was no truth behind this there was no evidence that this was really happening. This was all part of a show in order for him to make money. He preyed upon the week the people who want to believe in something. I’m not saying that it’s wrong to believe in something you can believe in whatever you want just be careful because there are a lot of people out there who can hurt you. To me, this is the fallacy of authority he’s claiming to cure these people when he is not a doctor
LikeLike
In this video “Trump on Clinton’s Personal Attacks” posted by ABC news during the campaign for the 2016 presidential election. Donald Trump is asked about the comments the Clinton’s made against him saying that “Just like he shouldn’t have his finger on the button, he should not have his hands on the economy” she supported this attack on Trump because he has filed for bankruptcy multiple times and consciously collected debt leading to hundreds of job losses. Donald trump then argues that Hillary Clinton is not capable of handling the economy because of her bad temperament. This is an example of an ad hominem fallacy, when a claim is directed personally at someone, ignoring the topic. Donald Trump criticized Clinton’s character and used it for as a reason as to why she is not capable at running the economy of the United States. Trump did not have any support as to what her bad temperament is and did not support why her temperament correlates to how well someone can run the economy. I don’t support these claims he made since he doesn’t have any sources to support his argument. One could say that Clinton’s claim against trump not being able to “have his finger on the button” was a personal attack and didn’t relate to the topic as much, making it a ad hominem fallacy as well, but she still gets her point across by saying he’s not capable of running the economy and uses facts to support her argument.
LikeLike
Kim Kardashian West recently said in an interview that she was pursuing a law degree in order to become a criminal lawyer. After facing backlash about how she is not properly equipped to be a lawyer, and her money and status is the only real reason as to why her journey will be made easier. West retorts by defending herself and explaining that the state bar exam does not take one’s social status into consideration. She furthers her argument by stating that her money and privilege did not and will not help her in her studies. I don’t have a problem with Kim Kardashian being a lawyer, but I do have a problem with her trying to shift the criticism away from herself by giving us a “follow your dreams” speech. She must acknowledge her privilege and use it to help others instead of denying it in order to make herself seem relatable. Her argument falls under the red herring fallacy as she strays from the actual argument of her having more help than any others in law school, and speaks of pursuing your dreams even when it seems impossible. In the same argument, she states that she is receiving mentorship from Jessica Jackson and Erin Haney; two criminal defense attorneys that defend those on death row. In West’s first year in law school, she has two experienced criminal defense attorneys tutoring her, an internship alongside Robert Shapiro and an open spot in his firm. The famous Robert Shapiro who was OJ Simpson’s attorney and a family friend of the Kardashians. I, again, have no problem with West wanting to pursue a career in law, but she has to admit that her privilege is helping her to succeed. Of course, no one is going to take her tests for her nor do any of her work, but she has a strong and knowledgable support group behind her.
LikeLike
I chose a tweet that was posted by Donald J. Trump earlier today. In the tweet, he states that the “Fake News Media” (aka anything and anyone he chooses to disagree with) are failing to properly examing the Mueller Report. He states that its principle conclusion was “no collusion with Russia” and that he believes the Russia “Hoax” is dead. He believes that news stations and articles that do not side with him on this matter are simply attempting to anger American citizens.
In his tweet I have found two possible fallacies. First, the circular argument fallacy. In the past Trump has always claimed to never be guilty of collusion with Russia. Now, despite actual evidence of such, he still believes he is innocent. Second, the causal fallacy. Trump claims that, since he has not been convicted of a charge OR punished for it, he has not done anything wrong.
Trump’s argument here is incorrect because Mueller had found plenty of evidence of collusion and obstruction of justice, however he cannot indict a sitting president. Meuller wrote, “The Russian contacts consisted of business connections, offers of assistance to the Campaign, invitations for candidate Trump and Putin to meet in person, invitations for Campaign officials and respresentatives of the Russian government to meet, and policy positions seeking improved U.S.-Russian relations.” According to William Barr’s “no conclusion”, the actual term is not a legally prosecutable action. Mueller wrote “Collusion is not a specific offense or theory of liability found in the United States Code, nor is it a term of art in federal criminal law. For those reasons, the Office’s focus in analyzing questions of joint criminal liability was on conspiracy as defined in federal law.” Donald Trump would have a clear bias here for himself rather than believing someone who is trying to convict him. He believes he is a great president, so of course he will not agree with anyone who questions that belief.
LikeLike
https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1119572078175367168 <– link to Donald Trump's tweet
LikeLike
I chose a commercial that has to do with the adapting animals just like what we discussed in class. I chose this commercial because the ad targets emotions and makes it looks very sad. So, by adapting a dog you basically save its life and make it happy, which is not a hundred percent true, although it triggers many emotions. This is especially directed towards emotional adults. In this commercial to catch your attention, they used a cute lonely dog to show its example because it doesn’t have a home. The dog sat there lonely and sad that he only has the old grey walls and a rusted old bowl to eat out of. That part when the human rejects the dog, the audience which would be around ages five and up. You feel the emotion and want to donate to stop that sad feeling you felt while watching the scenes behind the bars. Just like what we talked about in class, they can put any dogs behind bars to make it seem like they are in a bad situation. This particular instance of the commercial uses a very strong sense of ethos because of how relatable the setting is. It establishes a sense of family and love between pets and their owners.
LikeLike
Diego Solorio
Professor Ramos
ENGL-1B
20 April 2019
It’s well known that president Donald Trump is anti immigration and he is also known for voicing his opinions on social media. He recently tweeted “ Democrats must change the immigration laws FAST. If not, Sanctuary Cities must immediately ACT to take care of the illegal immigrants – and this includes Gang Members, Drug Dealers, Humma Traffickers, and Criminals of all shapes, sizes and kinds. CHANGE THE LAWS NOW!” Donald Trump is speaking directly to the Democratic Party and the Sanctuary Cities demanding them to change our immigration laws. Trump is also referring to immigrants as gang members, drugs dealers, human traffickers and criminals. In one tweet president Donald Trump has stereotyped immigrants into criminals. The only perspective Donald Trump has obtained on imagination is in a American citizen’s point of view, who has not been around an immigrant community. Personally coming from a immigrant family I strongly disagree with president Donald Trump. Not only because he has only seen and heard about the small portion of immigrants who are gang members, drug dealers, human traffickers… etc, but because he refuses to acknowledge the majority of immigrants who are hard working, smart, talented, and kind. Present Trump refuses to explore the true purpose of why immigrants decide to come to the United States of America. He immaturely refuses to believe that immigrants have a positive impact the size of Texas on the United States. If president Trump could put his pride aside and open his mind to explore the true purpose and personalities of our immigrants, he would gain the true perspective of our immigrants.
LikeLike
The article that I chose discusses the topic of how Americans are illiterate on scientific topics like climate change and pollution due to a lack of scientific education. The article goes on to discuss that the issue is not necessarily caused by a lack of education on the topics but more because of conflicting beliefs they favor not what they have learned based on scientific facts but the “confirmation bias” on those subjects. It closes with the idea that no matter how much information you provide to people they won’t decide to act on it unless the realize it is a problem that needs to be solved.
I kind of agree with this article because I have had run ins of a similar kind as far as people not really seeing that certain happenings in our world are problems, and also that they might see something as a problem but not necessarily for the reasons that science would say it is a problem. Their information is based on an excerpt of what they heard from someone talking about. I also don’t know how much of the article is based on a sound argument. In the article itself, it creates a few point of discussion but really on backs up its claims with non-specific evidence that makes it feel like the data they used is not 100% reliable.
LikeLike
The news article “Measles outbreak kills more than 1,200 in Madagascar” highlights an important topic that kills thousands of people, most of them being children. Due to lack of resources and poverty, people are losing their children. Only 58 percent of people were able to be vaccinated against Measles while the rate needed to be higher than 90 percent. The article summarizes what Measles is and the importance of vaccines. It also describes the outbreak of Measles in areas where poverty is at high rates and how catastrophic the disease is. The newspaper article holds a bias for people who suffer with Measles and also those who have lost someone due to this deadly disease. This is shown through the stories and words from people from Madagascar. There is no fallacy in this article as it is just stating statistics and news from the Measles outbreak in Madagascar. I agree with the statements made in this article because I feel that vaccines, although do not prevent the disease completely, helps keep the percent low. I also feel that wealthy countries, such as America, should be sending help to prevent poor people in Madagascar from dying. If not, the disease will continue to spread, even into our country and kill hundreds of lives. Just the other day someone was caught in the Airport after contracting Measles. Therefore, America should step in and send help, money, medicine to prevent this deadly disease from spreading. Their argument could be supported better by stating how wealthy countries could help and what that would do. It could also use more detail about the disease and how common it is, especially in poor areas.
https://www.apnews.com/0cd4deb8141742b5903fbef3cb0e8afa
LikeLike
The article I chose is written by Vox news in response to PewDiePie recommending other smaller youtube channels to viewers stating he enjoys their videos. The article claims that one of the channels listed is an anti-Semitic youtube channel and claims that PewDiePie has had many instances in which he has tried to spread antisemitism. In response to the first Vox news article, PewDiePie states he only liked the “anime review of Death Note on the channel.” The article goes further into stating that there was an “outcry against PewDiePie’s” recommendations and that other youtubers began citing it as an example of PewDiePie send dangerous messengers to teens. The article references previous instances in which PewDiePie has been the center of controversies regarding anti-Semitic or racial slurs.
This article contains many fallacies. The first fallacy is the ad populum fallacy. Throughout the article there are many instances in which the article states “the outcry against” or “many observers” or things along those lines to appeal to the majority. The issue with this is that after these sentences there were no sources showing data that there had been an outcry or many people stating these things. This is a fallacy because this is simply trying to appeal to the majority by getting them to bandwagon on a fact that has no evidence to back it up. Another fallacy within this article is the appeal to authority fallacy. I researched further into the sources of the data within the article, however most of the time it linked to another Vox article created by the same person on the same topic. The issue with this is that the information is not any more credible because it’s by the same author. Furthermore, the article is written by Aja Romano who is a reporter on internet culture. In a situation regarding statistics, facts, and such a reporter should not be the one stating facts without any sources from scientific data or expert analysts. This results in misinformation and bias in the information provided. Although there are many other fallacies I noticed within this article I will only address one more, the red herring fallacy. Midway through the argument presented by the article the topic shifts to PewDiePie’s previous use of the N word. The article is primarily targeted towards PewDiePie’s recommendations list of smaller youtubers, so why is this brought up within the article? Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying that this shouldn’t be an issue addressed, however in what use does it have in an article claiming that PewDiePie is spreading antisemitism and Nazi beliefs? By bringing this up the article is merely trying to distract the audience from critically thinking by showing a word that will invoke emotions out of the readers. I don’t wish to tell the reader how to think and would like to promote the idea of researching the topic yourself to formulate a proper opinion if interested. Personally, I believe both Vox and PewDiePie are responsible for fallacies and mistakes and both should be held accountable. I would like to research more into this before officially “choosing a side”, if i even choose one at all, and not be swayed by biased beliefs. The issue of course is that both sides of the argument are committing fallacies and bias, therefore it is very likely that the argument will never be settled due to lack of factual data.
LikeLike
https://www.vox.com/2018/12/13/18136253/pewdiepie-vs-tseries-links-to-white-supremacist-alt-right-redpill
LikeLike
I chose this advertisement on animal neglect or cruelty because it was relevant to what we have been discussing throughout our last session of class going into terms of pathos which expresses how it connects to targeting ones feelings and emotions. The argument and reasoning for the entire commercial is to show that in order by adopting these abandoned animals, it will hold great contribution in reducing the amount of unthinizations or put downs of the canines. The video purposely portrays cute dogs who seem to have been injured from physical abuse in order to use an attribute to reach the emotions of human beings. This is the simple tactic of how these organizations such as aspca reach the attention and take home tons of money each and every year from these kindhearted people who wake up everyday to help the world. I view the bias in this ad bc of the adoption of animals not in any form certainly mean that they are being properly taken care of. Anyone can establish a rescue home for animals in order to avoid all of the deaths, yet this necessarily doesn’t mean that they receive the love and affection they deserve. Just because they may post videos of these animals in a struggled setting such as behind cages doesn’t mean they are abandone or even beaten. It could be entirely staged for all the audience knows. This operation in itself is a prime example of an unsupported claim recording tears eyed animals on camera in order to receive help from giving people.
LikeLike
Video
LikeLike
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2019/04/20/us/politics/mueller-witnesses-trump.amp.html
It’s no secret that everyone has heard about the special council having concluded their investigation on the president and their potential cooperationwith Russia in the 2016 election. Americans have wanted to know what happened during the election for a while and now it is finally here. This article above sheds some light on a few of the general topics and questions of the actions that took place during the 2016 election between the president’s campaign, his campaign members, and the Russian government. Right away, we just recognize that the article is biased however, it is not necessarily a bad thing. The reason it is biased is that they are writing about this specific topic which means that they have some interest in the topic whether it be a negative interest or a positive one. In a short summary of what the article says, it highlights how President Trump actively tried to make the investigation swing towards his favor and innocence according to a few of the people in question under the investigation. It is important to note some more bias, this time negative as it seems that practically everyone talked about in this article portrays the president as a bad guy. While I am not suggesting his innocence, I do think it important to point out so that if you think he is guilty, you may take this into consideration and do a bit more research before blindly agreeing with what the article says and on the other hand, if you believe he is innocent perhaps after seeing how many portray him in this dark light you may see the reasons why they do and you may end up concluding that he is guilty if not completely then perhaps partly, and as well not blindly believing something. Furthermore, I wanted to mention how I believe there are two examples of fallacies in the article, the first being ad hominem which can be seen throughout the article where the president is under scrutiny for actions which they relate to his character. Once again, I am not suggesting he is a man of good character however, I am pointing out a fallacy which could potentially weaken the argument made in the article. The second fallacy is the slippery slope as a few witnesses mention some things that happened during the campaign which the article says that President Trump may choose to unleash his wrath on those who depend on him yet spoke out against him. The reason this is a fallacy is the fact that it may be a small action they performed which he would “dislike” and thus result in him ruining their life. Ultimately, I am curious as to the end results of this report and the president’s future as well as our country’s future.
LikeLike
The article I chose is on reality show star Khloe Kardashian. This article speaks on Khloe Kardashian’s picture she posted on instagram but fans were commenting on it talking about how she overly edited it and how her head doesn’t match her body or her thighs look weird and how something is extremely odd about the picture. She was being called out on something very irrelevant and unnecessary. It was just ridiculous because it comes to show how our society makes every little thing a really big deal, even though most irrelevant thing like for example your hair, nails, outfit, a post, or this. It doesn’t make sense as to why people take so much time out of their day to write something very negative about someone else on social media not only for them to see but also for the world to see as well. I ask myself, how do people even have time for this, how do they have time to sit behind a screen and comment negative things about the person like the person behind the screen is so holy and perfect. Our society today is so excited to see someone fail then to see them succeed. It’s very sad how our world works today. People laugh and make fun of someone else’s pain or sadness but when someone is happy, confident, and succeeding, people just bash, insult, and try to bring the good people down. Like why can’t society just enjoy and focus on the positive things in life rather than the negative. You can do a billion things right, but that one mistake you make, it will be the end of the world.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/…/Khloe-Kardashian-fire-editing-Instagram-photos.html
Khloe Kardashian is under fire AGAIN for editing her Instagram photos …
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-6773387/Khloe-Kardashian-fire-editing-Instagram-photos.html
LikeLike
I was scrolling through my twitter feed and I came across this post. This girl uploaded screenshots of a post that she saw on facebook. In the post, this lady was venting and explaining how she was so upset because her friend’s child passed away. This lady is clearly an anti-vaxer because she complains how she begged her friend not to vaccinate her child,but she did two days prior to the death. So, what is the first thing that comes to mind? The child clearly died of a disease or maybe she had an allergic reaction maybe even to the vaccination. Then you continue to read and it turns out that the child died in a car accident. She was hit by a drunk driver and this lady was blaming the vaccination for her death. She claimed that the heavy metals inside of the vaccination made the child “magnetic”.
This only goes to show how uneducated people can be on a topic, yet believe that they are in the right. She genuinely believed that the metals in the vaccination made the little girl magnetic even though there is no scientific proof. No common sense whatsoever or just the fact that it was clearly a drunk driver that hit the little girl, but this lady is so quick to blame the vaccination de to the fact that she is an anti-vaxer which in my opinion makes her ignorant. Most people are very quick to make assumptions without even realizing how wrong they are. People should really begin to educate themselves on a topic to actually understand a concept rather than being close minded and coming up with ignorant excuses to make their beliefs “true”
https://t.co/6g4bDic1er
LikeLike