This week we are talking about rhetoric and arguments. Great opportunity to begin analyzing a text you can use for your next essay. You can also find an image to describe and analyze.
First, summarize or describe the text.
Second, analyze the text using ethos, logos, and pathos and what we have been learning in class.
Include a link to the text. 200+ words. Comment below with your response.
In the video (Escaping the Pain of Human Trafficking), Markie Dell, explains how she was forced into human trafficking without even knowing. Markie Dell was only nineteen when she forced by intimidation, violence, threats to she and her family. She was a normal girl, who faced many insecurities as most young girls do. Someone who she trusted, a “friend”, after a night of fun, drove her to a strip club and said, “she now had to pay her back for the money she spent.” She threatened to kill her family if she didn’t dance and pay her back. That is where it began. This “friend” along with other men, held her captive. They forced her to continue to strip, make them money and these men raped her repeatedly. This went on for a year until a police officer rescued her and took her to a safe house. However, it was not over. The effects of her trauma led her to drugs, alcohol abuse and prostitution. This was her way of coping with the depression and trauma she had endured. It then, led to an attempt of committing suicide. Markie Dell shares her experience so she can raise awareness, forgive the people who misled her and to forgive herself. She emphasizes on deep healing and forgiveness so this may end the cycle.
Escaping the Pain of Human Trafficking | Markie Dell | TEDxDownsviewWomen
LikeLike
This picture shows a man carrying a sign on his back. The sign says, “I know 3 trades, I speak 3 languages, fought for 3 years, have 3 children, and no work for 3 months. But I only want one job.” Even without knowing the date this photo was taken, the words and the old-timey style can indicate that it was taken during the Great Depression. Which is correct, it was taken during the Great Depression in the 1930s. This photo can speak a lot for the entirety of the Great Depression era. Back then, everyone was out of work and suffering, with an exception for the insanely rich. This sign uses pathos, it is appealing to the audience’s emotions. The first part mentions that this man is an outstanding worker because he knows trades and 3 languages. This shows that even the most qualified worker was having a challenging time finding and keeping a stable job. However, the second part of the sign hits harder. This man tells the audience that he has 3 children and fought in the war for 3 years. Mentioning how he risked his life in war and how he has kids to take care of is impactful. It makes the audience sympathize with him because they would not want this for themselves.
https://rarehistoricalphotos.com/job-hunting-1930s/
LikeLike
HOUSEHOLD CHORES
This picture display a wife vacuuming while the husband sitting on the chair busy on the phone. By looking at the picture above, it is easy to quickly grab the fact that men are not engaging in household chores. Gender ideology and unequal distribution of labor has been putting double-burden on women from ages. Up till today, women still do most of the household work. Many societies still hold the belief that women have to do all the household chores. Girls were often taught by their mother to accept domestic role in which girl learn how to cook, how to clean house, and how to take care of children right from their very young age, while boys spend their time playing game. Some men are more domineering in under developing country due to what their culture teaches, so, majority of men do not like to participate in domestic work; instead, they want their wife to be serving them with everything they need even when some men cannot even provide for their family. Though the rate at which men participates in house work might have increase, but up till today, study shows that women still do most of the house work; whereas men rarely participate in household task. As women are now getting degree, majority of women are working long hours a week outside home and they come back home each day, to do another full time unpaid job, such as laundry, cleaning, cooking, grocery shopping, vacuuming, taking care of children, and helping children with school work. Some women still do all these work even when they are pregnant and raising kids. Many women don’t even like to talk or argue about this matter anymore because men do not see household task as part of their duty and it is sometimes overwhelming for women because they have to manage everything to keep peace in their home. Therefore, it is necessary and very important for men to engage and help out with domestic task.
https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/women-men-household-chores-domestic-house-gender
LikeLike
This ted talk video is about a man named Aaron Stark who talks about his experience about almost being a school shooter in 1996. His home life was very violent due to his drug addicting parents and was always moving to different schools so his home life was not stable. He had torn clothes and had a weight problem and was constantly bullied because of that. He was also bullied at home where people would tell him that he was worthless which makes things worse because your family at home should always be the support system that you need when you need help and he didn’t have that. He then became homeless at 16 because his parents kicked him out and let darkness take over and he started cutting himself. He says”when you have nothing to lose you can do anything” which drove him to do what he almost wanted to do. He then bought a gun and was ready. He did have a best friend who knew that dark place he was in and was still kind to him even when he knew that Aaron was constantly stealing for him. He explains how his friend offered him a meal and wanted to watch a movie together. That act of kindness made him feel like a person again and prevented him from shooting up his school. He now has a wife and is a father of 4. He is using ethos by sharing his experience. Pathos is also being used by him explaining how bad his home life was and describing his emotions. These things help catch an audiences attention. You never know what someone is going through in their lives and that is way we as people need to be kind of everyone. You being kind can change their lives completely, like how it changed his.
LikeLike
The image depicts how the American Dream is illustrating a happy, idyllic place that leads people to put themselves in dangerous situations, as long as they are able to go to America. The cartoon of the American Dream is illustrated as a giant sign surrounded by flashy lightbulbs on top of a giant American flag in front of a crumbling bridge with people walking on said bridge. The cartoon is attempting to illustrate how people will blindly follow the American Dream even if it constitutes of dangerous ways of getting there. Many people all over the world decide that their utopia is in fact the United States because of the compelling illustration of the American Dream, that promises jobs, money, happiness, and so much more. Personally, most people of the newest generations have not had to endure the challenges of immigration because they were born in the United States, but people like their parents are the ones that had to endure the suffrage, so they could be happy. For example, my father was born in Ecuador and later decided to relocate to the United States after hearing all the amazing opportunities available here. He stole away on a boat that was shipping bananas for about a week, and once he reached the United States he was to find a contact that was to help him settle in. After much trouble with no knowledge of English he found his contact and was helped in getting settled in. He later got a job at a factory and saved his money to bring my mother over, which he eventually did. And up to this day they have both worked in factories and continue to do so. Many people like my parents travel a long way for that American Dream that is in fact more of a dream than a reality. But although most people do not realize what they are getting into they still go through with it because no matter what happens they believe it will be better than whatever they would have had to deal with had they remained in their homelands. Immigrant parents endure suffrage so that others, like their children, could be blissfully happy. The cartoon shows a range of people from families to elderly people walking along the bridge that has in fact started to crumble. That part of the image is essentially illustrating the dangerous scenarios people allow themselves to be placed in with the ultimate goal of reaching the American Dream and bettering their lives, as well as finding a happiness that only America can provide them.
LikeLike
I chose this image as my journal topic, because this picture does have a thousand words. The image takes place in a school, either elementary or middle school. It’s shows the students stressed and studying too hard on the subjects math, reading, and writing. There’s a student trying to look out the window. Outside the window shows science, art, physical education, and just a beautiful day. The teacher in the classroom wants the student to get away from the window because he thinks the things that are outside the window might make the child be left behind on the studies the other kids are forced to study hard on.
The main point of the picture is that the government is cutting down art and fun activities to prepare students for standardized tests. The government has the power to control all education and educators. The teacher taking the student away from the window, works for the government, therefore he has to obey them and force her to do what the government wants.
I think this image really shows how unfair the education system can be due to it being controlled by the government. The ethos in this is the government control. How the schools and teachers have to follow them. The pathos in this is having the audience feel bad for the children who are being forced to study really hard on only those subjects, and feel empathy for the girl trying to do something fun, or do science and arts. The logos is that students should equally learn those subjects and learn fun subjects and do fun activities as well. The image overall really shows the unfairness of the government education control and really has people think and feel bad for the students in the picture.
https://clwproject1.weebly.com/image-9.html
LikeLike
The link is to an image displaying a graph of population trends of Japan for the Heisei Era (1989-2018) gathered by the Japanese Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications in October, 2018 . The Japanese overall Japanese population had a growth period from 1989 to 2008, growing by around 500,000 people in the years 1989 to 1993, then showing slower growth from 1993 onward. The overall population was 128 million at its peak between 2008 and 2009, at which point population growth became negative. In 1989 the population of Japan was 123 million; in 2018 the population numbers around 126 million. The population of Japan has shrunk by about 200,000 per year since 2010.
The graph (Population Change in Japan During the Heisei Era) is a visual representation of data gathered by a governmental organization. It uses professional language with no negative or positive connotations, such as: Overall, increase/decrease, axis, left/right, and population. The other factors of the image are ordered years and population numbers. It is a completely facts-based visual aid. Therefore the graph’s rhetorical value is in ethos and logos. Ethos, or credibility, is established because the data is from a governmental organization. Logos, or the images logical appeal, is that the graph displays pure, factual data. Any emotional response to the graph would be completely dependent on the viewer’s interpretation since the creator has not purposely included pathos into the image. In conclusion, the above mentioned image is a pure manifestation of data and could be used to as evidence in support of any side of an argument since it is completely unbiased.
LikeLike
I chose this image as my journal topic, because this picture does have a thousand words. The image takes place in a school, either elementary or middle school. It’s shows the students stressed and studying too hard on the subjects math, reading, and writing. There’s a student trying to look out the window. Outside the window shows science, art, physical education, and just a beautiful day. The teacher in the classroom wants the student to get away from the window because he thinks the things that are outside the window might make the child be left behind on the studies the other kids are forced to study hard on.
The main point of the picture is that the government is cutting down art and fun activities to prepare students for standardized tests. The government has the power to control all education and educators. The teacher taking the student away from the window, works for the government, therefore he has to obey them and force her to do what the government wants.
I think this image really shows how unfair the education system can be due to it being controlled by the government. The ethos in this is the government control. How the schools and teachers have to follow them. The pathos in this is having the audience feel bad for the children who are being forced to study really hard on only those subjects, and feel empathy for the girl trying to do something fun, or do science and arts. The logos is that students should equally learn those subjects and learn fun subjects and do fun activities as well. The image overall really shows the unfairness of the government education control and really has people think and feel bad for the students in the picture.
https://clwproject1.weebly.com/image-9.html
LikeLike
The attached image is an art piece created by a famous graffiti artist known as Banksy. Most of the art that he creates is engaging rather than passive. He usually has something to say without actually saying it and leaves it up to the viewers eyes to decide what they get from it. This image is of a red heart shaped balloon being carried away from a young girl. At first glance some may believe that this image is of a kind of loss. If dissected the young girl could be seen as an innocence. The red heart represents love. This could signify a loss of love or innocence. Others may see that this image holds more to it. Balloons are usually a joyful presence. Beside the painting are the words, “There is always hope.” Which brings hope to the image. Overall this art holds loss, hope, love and freedom. I think looking deeper into it represents children losing some innocence by being steered toward feeling hopeless but the message is to not give up given having no control of losing something or that of being so close to reaching what you want. I think this picture is important because its an image that makes you think for yourself. The art is what you make of it.
LikeLike
CHILDREN OF IMMIGRATION
the increase in work raids have increased in the US and the fact that more than 5 million children have at least one undocumented parent is enough to consider a different tactic. Parent separation is affecting these children emotionally & financially. These children depend on their parents solely and they are left without both parents in some instances and without a warning. Children are who pay the price of these work raids, either they move to another country which they’ve never known of or have to adapt to life without one or both parents to stay in this country which has better opportunity.
https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fcdn.americanprogress.org%2Fcontent%2Fuploads%2F2017%2F07%2F20131012%2FDACAEarlyChildhoodBrief-1024×683.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.americanprogress.org%2Fissues%2Fearly-childhood%2Freports%2F2017%2F07%2F31%2F436377%2Ftrumps-immigration-policies-harming-american-children%2F&docid=8zTpVM_jADjUuM&tbnid=WJwFqXwQTEVsYM%3A&vet=10ahUKEwjs3deUp-XlAhULGTQIHe6ZDKkQMwicASgsMCw..i&w=1024&h=683&client=safari&bih=653&biw=1280&q=children%20and%20immigration&ved=0ahUKEwjs3deUp-XlAhULGTQIHe6ZDKkQMwicASgsMCw&iact=mrc&uact=8
LikeLike
In this Mr. Clean ad, the text states that “This Mother’s Day, We Get Back To The Job That Really Matters”. The ad showcases a mother and her daughter. The subtext of this ad is that women are meant to clean and that they should be the ones to do it, not the men. By using Mother’s Day, the ad implies that the Mr. Clean product is a good gift to give to a woman because women enjoy cleaning. By showing the daughter in the ad, the ad is saying that only young girls need to learn how to clean, not young boys. The Mr. Clean mascot implies that men give women what they need to do their cleaning, the cleaning women need to do, and the women do it. The ad misuses not only logos, but ethos and pathos too. It deceives the consumers and relies on sexual stereotypes. Logos is misused because the ad doesn’t tell you everything and fails to tell the viewer that men are capable of cleaning too. The ad uses tricks to deceive the consumer rather than logic. This ad tries to present their products as a desirable gift for women. Consumers are tricked because Mr. Clean uses Mother’s Day to make it seem like this is a great gift but in reality, mothers and women are being discriminated against. This ad insinuates that if mothers or women are given a Mr. Clean product they will start cleaning more as a result. It misuses ethos because it relies on stereotypes that do not exist. Believing that women’s only role is to clean is a stereotype of the past. Today, women and men are thought of as equals, who can do whatever they choose to do with their life. Second, the ad appeals to the authority that men think they have over women. This is an incorrect use of ethos because people are equal regardless of gender. This ad also misuses pathos because it relies on sexual stereotypes. The ad is targeted towards women of all ages and races. This ad wants women to believe that they only have one role in society, and that is to be a wife and mother. This is a bad ad because it is sexist and portrays women in a negative light.
View at Medium.com
LikeLike
The Du-rag
When you walk by a young black male what do you see? How do you feel? Do you stop by and look at his style? Do you roll your eyes believing he can do better? Now, let’s evaluate a young black male in a du-rag; what strikes you in his appearance? The answer is nothing else but his du-rag.
In recent times, over a dozen young black males have been threatened by both the authorities and the society at large for putting on a du-rag. They have been considered criminals and predicted to amount to nothing. It’s important to note that all these are not without precedent, as a couple of black males did commit crimes while having the du-rag on. But as the “We Should All Be Feminist” author, Chimamanda Adichie would say, ‘give a people a single story and that is what they will ever know.’ A single-story depicts stereotypes and the problem with stereotypes is not their lack of truth but their impotency due to lack of information (ie. incomplete).
As a young black male, I will love to share the beauty and purpose of the du-rag. The du-rag plays a great role in the daily lives of Africans, African Americans, and anyone blessed enough to receive the melanin richness and our kinky (wooly) hair. It has brought peace among youngsters in the hood as it represented the daily but loving struggle of young black males and females trying to keep their hair straight. And talk about the joy attained when these kinky curls of ours start making waves. Imagine the wonders of a black boy’s smile.
In conclusion, the du-rag is nothing but a clothing accessory. Just like one’s sweatpants and your white tees, one does not get called a criminal for putting on those, nor does one get threatened by the cops. The du-rag is a part of the black culture and as many other cultural entities, it should be respected as much.
Joseph, Brian. “Who criminalized the Durag?” GQ. 22 March 2017.
https://www.gq.com/story/who-criminalized-the-durag
Garcia, Sandra E. “The Durag Explained”, New York Times. 14 May 2018
LikeLike