Locate an article, news report, or social media post to respond to. You can also respond to any of the articles or topics discussed in the class.
First, summarize the text.
Second, respond to the article. Why did you pick it? How does it connect to our class?
Include a link to the text. 200+ words. Comment below with your response.
http://theantisense.com/2018/12/18/the-science-behind-the-crispr-babies-lulu-and-nana/
Dr. Jiankiu He, a Chinese biological engineer educated in America, created the first genetically modified humans. Lulu and Nana are had their genomes edited in the embryonic stage with CRISPR (Cluster Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats) Cas9 gene editing technology to render the babies immune to HIV. Dr. He received tremendous backlash for proceeding with the experiments without consensus from regulatory or ethical agencies. The scientific community bemoaned the procedures as unethical and extremely dangerous. Critics were especially strong on the potential for off-target effects, which is when the gene editing causes changes that were not intended or predicted to happen. Despite the public outcry, Dr. He has brought forth all his research and experimental data to demonstrate the heavy deliberation and care put into the procedure, an to demonstrate that it was not just a publicity stunt.
This article relates to many topics we covered in class. It first serves as an example for the proposed idea of human genome editing technology being deregulated and becoming a major academic, clinical, and business field. Dr. He is the first man to publicly genetically engineer human embryos and allow them to come to term. He is in effect forcing the technology onto the spotlight by his actions. The second topic related to class that can be analyzed is the rhetoric of both the article and Dr. He’s actions. Dr. Josiah Zayner, the article’s author, is a self-proclaimed biohacker, a proposer of radical technological change. His views on the Dr. He’s work is obviously positive; throughout the article Dr. Zayner uses technical details and facts surrounding Lulu and Nana’s creation to persuade his audience that the technology should move forward. Other than using logic, Dr. Zayner appeals to Dr. He’s professionalism and painstaking attention to detail in his experiment to convince the audience of the experiment’s solid basis. Lastly, we covered monster theory in class, and this helps to explain the backlash Dr. He received for experimenting with the lives of human babes. Altering the code of life through genetic engineering is a controversial topic due to its relative novelty and mystery; people fear what they do not understand. Genetic engineering and the “mad scientists” like Dr. He who carry it out stand at the “boundary of becoming”, standing between the known and the unknown. Similarly, Dr. Frankenstein from Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein or the Modern Prometheus” messes with the natural, established order by reanimating the dead, giving life to his own monstrosity in dead flesh. It can be argued that Dr. Frankenstein himself is the monster in the novel, not his creation, because of his wanton disregard for the sanctity of life and his abandonment of his own “child”. However, going back to the real Dr. Jiankiu He, our real life Frankenstein carried out his experiment with the utmost diligence and has demonstrated the potential for what can be. Whether he is a monster or not will depend on how our culture adapts to the future.
LikeLike
writing a remorseful letter to the judge and putting everything done to him in perspective so that it could be taken into consideration when his upcoming sentencing trial approaches. he states that he still feels as a role model which in a sense i agree because depends on how you choose to look at his situation considering his influence in social media he can be looked as an example as to why you shouldn’t involve yourself in gangs. these gang members took advantage of his position and extorted him, kidnapped him, and threaten his life, all of to which are more than valid reasons to sympathize with him as well as considering this as a warning for young boys who are thinking of joining a gang.
Rapper Tekashi 69 who is known for his controversial social media outrages against other rappers . viewed as a “monster” for his gang affiliation; who is now serving time in prison who is awaiting his sentencing on Dec 18. is a prime example of a product of his environment with his involvement with the wrong crowd. i chose this article for just that and because i think people often don’t sympathize with these type of cases. as well as believe in giving people second chances with a fair sentencing.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/still-consider-myself-role-model-161246393.html
LikeLike
So, I just happened to watch Tim Minchin’s music video on prejudice. Prejudice, as we discussed in class, is a preconceived opinion that is not based on reason or actual experience. To cut the grammar short, prejudice is simply being a pain in someone else’s ass. Tim Minchin did a marvelous song while creating his musical comedy on prejudice. I can’t seem to ignore the second half of the song where he began singing about being called a ginger. Tim states, “only a ginger can call another ginger GINGER…” As comedic as this may seem it correlates with a lot in the society today. Here’s an example, black individuals in society today make it clear that only people of the black race are allowed to call them “Nigga”. Connecting the dots, I think my point is completely clear and understandable.
Also, in the animation, Storm, by the same artist, Tim Minchin, we see how he harmonize prejudice to ignorance. And I must say, that was a masterpiece. This is because giving opinions based on one’s ideologies and not extensive research is complete ignorance. Tim Minchin also encourages the need for critical thinking (which we discussed in class). He makes us understand that thinking critically doesn’t mean we’re giving up our beliefs, however, it helps us understand others around us while acquiring new knowledge.
Minchin, Tim. “Ready for This?: Prejudice.” Kobalt Music Publishing: Youtube. 24 March 2010
Youtube. “Tim Minchin’s Storm The Animated Movie”. 7 April 2011.
LikeLike
In this article, Stephanie Rothman informs us of a woman from Junction City that was accused of child abuse. The police said she admitted that she “popped him in the face” and “accidentally” hit him in the nose. The child had a bloody nose, but the mother and her boyfriend tell the police that they didn’t see any blood. The boyfriend continues to admit that his girlfriend hits her child when misbehaving, and says that, “Any parent would do that.” The mother and her boyfriend genuinely think they did nothing wrong by hitting their child hard enough to make him bleed. The kid is only three years old, and although they think it’s good parenting, the child may see them as monsters. The boyfriend continues to justify her actions. The police also say that they were having sex in front of the child while smoking weed. Most people would see this couple as monsters, yet the mother was released from police custody. I chose this article because I thought it was crazy that the mother was released, even if the police are still working on the case. This relates to our class because the couple claims they aren’t monsters, even though they constantly cause physical harm to their child to the point of making him bleed. No child should be afraid of their parents. The boyfriend even goes as far as calling it a mistake. He says, “We’re not monsters, we’re all human beings, we all make mistakes.” Purposefully doing something over and over again, knowing it’s harming the child, is not a mistake. They’re just sorry that they got caught.
https://nbc16.com/news/local/i-didnt-see-no-blood-junction-city-mother-accused-of-child-abuse-out-of-jail
LikeLike
https://www.cnn.com/2019/12/12/tech/ring-security-camera-hacker-harassed-girl-trnd/index.html
In this article it shows a video were a person has hacked into the Ring security camera of a family in Mississippi. Ashley LeMay had installed the camera inside her daughters’ room to keep an eye on her while she went to worked overnight shift. But little did she know that four days after she installed them someone would hack the camera. Ashley’s daughter was in her room when she heard the song “Tiptoe through the Tulips” playing through the camera’s speaker. When the little girl said who is that, a man replayed with “I’m your best friend. I’m Santa Claus, don’t you want to be my best friend?”. This article connects to what we have learned in class about monsters. As we can see in the video the hacker the “monster” installs fear into the little girl by playing a scary song out of nowhere as she was playing in her room. This video also connects to Cohens monster thesis in which it says that the monster always gets away. As it says in this article, this is not the first time that someone has gained access to someone’s ring camera. Several other families have also been terrorized by a person talking to them though the cameras speaker. This shows how the monster always gets away, no matter if those families disconnect their cameras, there will always be others who will try and hack into people’s home, computer, or phone cameras. I chose this article because I was disgusted to see how there are people who have nothing better to do but to harass people through their home security cameras.
LikeLike
I watched this Ted-Ed youtube video on the Allegory of the Cave by philosopher Plato. Plato’s story of the Allegory of the Cave is the most famous story in philosophy. The story
showcases two groups of people; one born prisoners to the darkness of the cave forced to face
the wall at all times, and another group of people on the other side of that wall making
reflections of things from the shadow the bonfire light reflects. The Allegory of the Cave
describes “shadows” on the cave wall which we are taught from birth to be perceived as real
forms. In today’s modern society, controlled by the media, we can see the similarities of the
people in the Allegory of the Cave. If we apply this allegory to modern life, the cave is the
world, the wall with shadows would be the television or our phones, instead of echoes we have
radios. It can even be false or hateful political/religious ideologies to scientific racism; just about
anything that is bartered as truth and fact. But most important, it is in the light we realize the
media does not report news but rather they aim to deceive, control, and manipulate. The shadows
media also reflect ranges from political or religious ideologies that are false or hateful. The
Allegory of the Cave is relevant even today’s media propaganda and politics and that is why I
chose to write about this topic in depth. Activist, Minister Martin Luther King Jr. once said in a public speech, “Everything that we see is a shadow cast by that which we do not see. “ King believed that you should dare to venture back into the cave of shadows in hopes of freeing the shackled prisoners.
LikeLike
Juan Espinoza
Espinozaj17.je@gmail.com
A Lawyer is disbarred for claiming his paralegal’s work as his own. The Knoxville lawyer made false and exaggerated time entries over charging his client for over $103,000 in legal fees for the alleged time spent fighting Lowe’s over a discovery issue. Lawyer, Loring Justice claimed that he had kept “contemporaneous records”, of which time was spent locating and deposing a store human resources manager but this work was not his own, it was his paralegals. When all was said and done and the legal bills were inspected it turned out 17 items were nearly identical to invoices submitted by the paralegal. A background check was check revealed that Justice was a Yale graduate who had once clerked for a federal appeal judge and while the paralegal had attended yale with Justice they didn’t have a Tennessee law license. Its because of this that the Supreme Court’s board of Professional Responsibility had recommended a 1-year suspension rather than a disbarment. The suspension was then modified to a disbarment as Justice was “intentional deceit” and” total lack of remorse” left no alternative. Later in an interview Justice claimed to Tennessee Supreme Court is serving interest groups and is “disturbingly dishonest”. In his closing statement he laments the loss of his license not for himself but for his clients and interests of an uncorrupted and fair legal system in Tennessee.
We covered a variety of different topics in class but the most impactful lesson in the quarter was understanding monster theory. Monsters come in variety of shapes and sizes, what makes them monsters can vary depending on the time and place that’s one of the many lessons that we learned in class. Sometimes the people who are supposed to protect you turn out to be the monsters and the real hero’s go without the credit they deserve. In this case and probably many more the paralegal is the real hero or heroine. Some of the worst monsters can not only take your time, time you won’t get back but also take credit for your work. Another lesson that was learned not only in 1B but 1A was the value and respect when owing credit to someone else’s work in our papers. Its something we should try our best to acknowledge not only in writing but in life. Sometimes an honest mistake is made similar to the Lawyer but then those who did the real work, the paralegal won’t get the recognition they deserve. The last thing I will mention that was important in our lectures was the importance of caring. There are countless topics we discussed but it what tied it together was us. When we care about something we think, write and speak critically and passionately about it. Though the Lawyer was in the wrong there were good intentions behind it maybe it really was an honest mistake, hopefully his paralegal gives him a chance someday. When we want to understand something more to leave ignorance behind and educate ourselves so we can give back we should give the other side a chance.” When you want to see someone succeed in life, you want to be there to help in any way possible, you care about them not for what they can do for you, you value them for who they, that’s love”. -a paralegal, who’d I like to know better
http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/lawyer-is-disbarred-after-he-is-accused-of-claiming-paralegal-work-as-his-own
LikeLike
This news article is about a Milwaukee man who go thrown acid to his face by a white man. The white man had approached the peruvian man and got into an arguement and as it escalated the white man threw battery acid to his face and told him “go back to your country.” This is obviously a hate crime. This semester we talked a lot about racism and this article reminded me of the ted talk video of the KKK. Its not exactly like the Ted Talk video but it reminded me of how ignorant people can be. People don’t get that were are all humans. We were all born the same way, but we are stilll judged on where we come from. I’m Salvadorian and when I tell people I am they always tell “your not salvadorian, your not dark, they’re suppose to be dark.” We are judged by our color. Ignorant people like that white man make this worlda horrible place to live in which gives people a reason not to have kids anymore. People think that racism was bad before or that it doesn’t exist, but it exists more than ever now. Its up to us to stop the racism that happens. Taking this class encouraged to do more for future generations.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/latino/milwaukee-man-suffers-acid-burns-his-face-alleged-racist-attack-n1075651
LikeLike
This week I chose the case of the twenty-two year old rapper, SixNine in court. He was charged of many things, including murders, drug transportations, illegal actions and possession of illegal substances. The court tape went viral due to what he had explained about his childhood causing his PTSD and mental illness. This topic relates to the class because he admits his behavior may have started because of what happened to him when he was younger. SixNine states that someone killed his father in front of the house, and people ran to call SixNine to come out, as he did, he saw his father’s dead body right in front of him. This caused PTSD and a lot of mental issues. Some people grow stronger into a better person, and others lash out negatively. In class, we have been talking about causes that make a monster come about, and this court case shows it well. If SixNine didn’t experience what he did, he probably wouldn’t of have done all the things he is charged for. His childhood caused him to act the way he did. He wasn’t using it as an excuse at all, but people do see it as a leading point. https://youtu.be/YhBCjO7J0qw
LikeLike
The article “Two Ways to Belong in America” by Bharati Mukherjee details the lives of two immigrant sisters. One sister which willfully adapts to American culture and in a sense loses her own culture and one sister who although follows along with American culture is still in a sense faithful to her own and plans on returning to her home in the possible future. The article makes the reader think about immigration in our present day and how it affects people in different ways, as well as how most immigrants tend to adapt to American culture in an attempt to Americanize themselves, so they could fit in. But by doing so most of them tend to forget their roots and their culture. I think this article helps with the monster theory that we learned in class. Not all monsters are fictional and not all are people. I feel like this article really illustrated how monsters have different forms such as culture. Our American culture is that of privilege and we over influence others in negative ways as they begin to forget their cultures and replace it with an American one.
LikeLike
Maria L. N
Acid attack victims faces years of recovery after inadequate medical attention.
A 26 years old Oaxaca woman faces years f recovery after she was doused with sulfuric acid in an attack her family claims ordered by a former state lawmaker.
Maria Elena, a talented saxophone player an travel agency employee was attacked with acid on September by a man who requested help to apply for a passport. As Maria Elena was fill out a form, the poured a bottle of acid over her, burning her face, chest, and legs. After three months in the hospital in Oaxaca City, where medical personnel lacked the expertise to treat her severe burns, she was transferred to the National Rehabilitation Institute for burns victims in Mexico City. The victm’s family is convinced that the attack was ordered by a former Oaxaca lawmaker with whom she was previously in a relationship.
In class we learned monsters can be real or not but in this case we have one monster and one monstrosity. The monster is the person who poured a bottle of acid in her face ,chest and legs and the monstrosity is a medical personnel who treated her with out experience. Maria Elena now is depressed as a result of her predicament and the doctors said she would rather be death in the condition in which she finds herself. The article said that three people was involved in this case but that those responsible will not go unpunished.
LikeLike