This week we have been focusing on visuals and rhetoric. You can analyze an image or find an interesting text to analyze rhetorically. You can also locate an article, news report, or social media post to respond to. You can respond to any of the articles or topics discussed in the class.
First, summarize what the post is saying and what you understand them to be arguing.
Second, respond to the article with what we have been learning in class.
- Analyze an image or visual post.
- Evaluate the argument they are making.
- Explain any bias you see in the post.
- Point out unsupported claims.
- If you agree, help them better support their argument. If you disagree, explain why.
- Notice the use of Ethos, Logos, and Pathos
Make sure your journal response is at least 200+ words long. Comment below with a link and your response.
In his speech, “The Ballot or the Bullet,” Malcolm X declares 1964 as the year of the ballot or the bullet, freedom or revolution, “liberty or death.” His main purpose of delivering this speech was to unite African Americans in their struggle against a government lead largely by whites and to convince them that they have more power than they could possibly imagine, as long as they remain united.
They have the power to put a president in the White House, they have the power to take back their communities, and they have the power to gain freedom that have been denied for hundreds of years.
He uses Logos to show that black people have been victimized by being outsmarted by the government, he uses ethos to establish his character and status as a freedom fighter as well as to unite black Americans, and he uses pathos to elicit powerful emotions from his audience and urge them to take action. The pathetic appeal is one of his stronger appeals. He uses a lot of repetition throughout his speech to cause the audience to feel enraged. Ultimately, Malcolm X’s speech “The Ballot or the Bullet”, was written to help fuel the minds of Black America. This speech ties together everything that he stood for.
LikeLike
In this image posted on Reddit of game 3 of the 2019 NBA championship shows the Golden State Warriors fans leaving early during the game. At about 1:28 left in the game, the Golden State fans desert their team due to them being down 12 points, yet this isn’t the last game as they still had about 4 or fewer games left to determine the champion. This image shows the true bandwagoners of the Golden State Warriors as some people stay to support their team well others are in a rush to leave because of traffic. This can relate to class as we learn about the different types of appeal such as the appeal to bandwagon as the Golden State fans do so by leaving their team because they lost a match. The argument here is due to the trend or winning state of a team people will join in and how to explain how loyal they have been with their team although they only do so because they are winning. The image is biased towards Golden State bandwagoners as they make fun of them because they pretend to support their team but when they lose, they desert their team. The image also contradicts the aspect of ethos as the credibility for the warrior’s fans disappears after they leave their team in the dust losing their trust in the process.
LikeLike
As I was scrolling through Instagram, an influencer, I follow posted something I enjoyed. It was a short video talking about starting a new challenge. The challenge that had been proposed was not necessarily a physical activity such as; snorting a condom or eating a tide pod. Instead, the challenge was one in which attention was brought to ourselves, the people around us, the things we treasure, and why they are important. Teale Vucinich started a 7-day #gratitudechallenge; the directions are to make one video a day for seven days, talking about one thing you are grateful/thankful for. The first day the influencer speaks about his gratitude for his physical fitness level, the following day, he goes on to express gratitude for his job, the tests of faith he has gone through, and today, his third day he posts about his gratitude for his family. Every day he posts, the influencer tags that days amount of people to nominate them to pick up the challenge. For example, on day one, the influencer nominated one person; on day two, Teale nominated two people, and so on. I have been checking in everyday to like the current video and follow people who decide to continue the challenge; this is my way of showing support. I feel Teal is arguing for awareness as well as life itself, reminding people why life is worth living. The bias in the post comes from the place of often when people are going through a rough patch, or as Teal referred to it “trials,” it can be hard for them to see any reason to be grateful. I wish the influencer had prefaced the challenge topic talking about why we should spend time being grateful or thankful as well as possible topic ideas of what to be thankful for that way people have the motivation to complete the challenge even if they do not connect with Teale’s reason’s to be grateful/thankful. The tone of the post was positive and excited; the influencer refers to his own experience and aims to involve the audience. In my opinion, Teale could have done more with Ethos to persuade the audience to participate only two-fifths of people he has nominate have continued the challenge so far. On day three, Teale does become more emotional, giving the audience more enticement to continue the challenge themselves. Teale is being thorough in appealing to different emotions and is fully using Logos by following up with why he is grateful for the different topics he is discussing.
LikeLike
I posted the website link but it did not show as having gone through do just incase. https://www.instagram.com/tealevucinich/?hl=en
LikeLike
(https://static01.nyt.com/images/2020/01/31/world/10australialetter139-1/31ozf-fires-kangaroo-facebookJumbo.jpg )
This picture was widely used by many whether for articles, instagram posts, and more when the Australian fires were acknowledged by the media. It is showing the fire burning what seemed to be some sort of building or home along with a kangaroo nearby. The argument people who use this photo are mainly trying to make is that the Australian fires are severe and are taking away people’s homes as well as the animals along with their lives. It can also be how the earth as a whole is suffering (climate change) and the Australian fire is one of the ways how. I’m not sure if there’s a bias, however most people who used the picture mainly used it to describe how heartbreaking it is and to help by donating or sharing with others.
Pathos was clearly used as emotions such as sadness is supposed to be evoked. The sadness/pity is meant to encourage people into wanting or actually helping. I do believe the image does a good job at using pathos as I myself felt emotion when I saw it as I felt for the animals and people going through the disaster of the fires. This relates to the lesson of rhetoric and how it’s used to sway people to believe in a certain way.
LikeLike
https://abcnews.go.com/International/photos/coronavirus-outbreak-sparks-global-health-emergency-68676204/image-68751866
While scrolling through abc news picture gallery I came across this particular picture. With the corona virus being a big topic still in the news today I wasn’t surprised to see many pictures of what was going on. Although this picture is a simple one of a woman in what looks like the middle of the road you can see her frustration and emotions in the picture. The caption on the side explains that Lu Yuejin was pleading with police officers during a check point outside of Wuhan, China lockdown due to the corona virus to let her daughter pass through because she needed to receive cancer treatment. Eventually the police let both Lu Yuejin and her daughter through to await an ambulance. I felt that this image had to do with pathos. They used this woman’s name and described her situation to help you relate to her and feel emotion. Once knowing the emotion behind the picture you can be understand and feel the image. They used pathos by telling this woman’s story but this is also ethos because her story also helps to create some credibility behind the story. This relates to our class on Pathos and how images are used and created to make you feel a certain emotion and how they have a purpose.
LikeLike
This news was in Daytona Beach, Florida. Where Ryan Newman added one more terrifying accident to his NASCAR career. Which caused the races to stop that day.
Newman slid across the finish line in a pile of crumpled metal, with sparks flying when his car stopped and fuel poured on the track frightfully near the flames. The fans were speechless when the track workers placed large black screens around Newman’s car and worked to get him out. They had to wait two hours to exhale. Newman was in a terrifying crash on the last lap of the Daytona 500 on Monday, and everyone feared the worst. NASCAR has not had a fatality in its since 2001.
After two hours, NASCAR announced that Newman had non-fatal injuries and was in serious condition at a Medical Center. Information had been expected so knowing that information brings relief. Said the global director of Ford Performance Motorsports. The entire Ford family is sending positive thoughts for recovery.
Security teams rushed to Newman’s Ford and worked to get him out of his seat. The car caught fire when it stopped and had to turn on its tires before Newman could unbuckle. Appealing to fear was in that report for Newman’s life. Ethos is involved in this report because it is a story reported in a newscast that is credible in its way of delivering the news, and there is evidence that this event was real. Pathos is also visible in this news because the emotions were moved with insecurity, sadness and fear that this gentleman would lose his life. And logos, the probability of death was strong due to the intensity of the accident.
LikeLike
https://www.thedodo.com/close-to-home/dog-waits-on-porch-for-family-to-return
While scrolling through Facebook I came across this post of an abandoned dog on his porch named Cupid. The post was from a rescue team talking about how he is such a sweet dog and needs a new home. The dogs owners packed up their stuff and just drove off leaving him behind. He stayed on the porch until neighbors finally called Janine guido from a rescue team. Janine says she found the dog eating from a dumpster and when trying to approach him he ran off frantically scratching at his door. Finally Janine Earned his trust after about thirty minutes and was taken to the rescue shelter where she states he has been nothing but the sweetest dog. I don’t see any bias being shown in this post due to the fact that anyone is able to adopt this dog. I believe this dog truly does deserve a loving home because he didn’t deserve to be abandoned in such a cruel way. He was left without any food, water or shelter. This post is using ethos because the post was written by a writer from New York and showing a credible rescue employee and team called speranza animal rescue. Pathos was being used by making the audience feel sadness. This really convinces the audience to adopt cupid. Logos was also shown through the pictures because you can see proof of the poor dog sitting on his porch looking sad and empty, in the second picture you see him scratching at his door.
LikeLike
https://nypost.com/2020/02/16/trump-blames-fake-news-for-reporting-wind-blew-down-part-of-border-wall/
In this post I read that the wall Trump started to build his wall dividing Mexico and the wind knocked it down. The wall that is supposed to keep illegal immigrants out of America was knocked down by 30-40 mile per hour winds. Trump claims that the wall had fresh cement which allowed it to fall very easily. Trump also claimed that the wall would be up and stronger than ever in no time. Personally I feel that this is funny, a wall made to keep people out of a country was knocked down by wind. If wind can knock down the wall imagine what people would do to it. Trump claims that the news was fake so then expressed that the cement was fresh and nothing would be able to knock it down once it was dry. In the picture of the wall it is noticeable that the wall could have been very easily knocked down so clearly the news was not fake.
LikeLike
The picture will be sent by email
This image depicts a buff, handsome, and white man standing in his underwear that has Under Armour written over it. In the background there is a beautiful lady who is barely clothed in bed. The audience that this ad is for are men because by seeing this image of a handsome man with these women both half naked it will cause men to think that by getting these underwear they’ll be more attractive to women. The element that is used in this ad is sex appeal so that the audience will think this product is more attractive if they get it. We have seen products like this before that use similar advertisements because in this society sex is percieved to be important. The company has advertised similar ads before and it is all centered around the idea that if you buy this product you will become more attractive to women. The room that the two of them are in is very fancy and may tie in the idea that if you have this product you must be very wealthy. By showing that the other items they have are expensive they would think that by having this product they will also be seen as rich. Anything that will draw positive attention may lead to the product being sold. Young men who want to appear attractive with looks and money may get these products in hopes that women will notice the objects and come to these conclusions. As outlandish as this may seem there are many people who do this with celebrity products.
LikeLike
In this commercial there are people looking at or holding up photos of their family members with sad look in their eyes as a sad song plays in the background. This message this commercial is trying to send to the audience is to stop speeding and their argument is that speeding can lead to death. Not only that but speeding can have a big impact on you and others around you. I feel like this commercial does a good job of using pathos because they are trying to tell a story and make the audience feel a specific way about an issue in attempt to stop a problem. They’re trying to make the audience sad in order to get their point across and make it relatable to them in the sense that this can happen to anyone like your family member or friend. I feel like this commercial lacks Logos because there are a couple statements at the end of the commercial and one of them is “Speeding drivers are the biggest killers on our roads,” but there are no facts or data supporting the statement. Also when the family members hold up the photos of the member who was killed in speeding accident it stated the date when it happened, but this might be false information as well. We as an audience don’t know whether its true or not but we relate it because it makes us feel a certain way. It makes us sad and we start to think, “that can happen to me.”
LikeLike
This video is an advertisement that Donald Trump posted on his Instagram page. The video shows a guy in a motorcycle almost being hit with a guy in a suv, he proceeds to cuss at him the entire way for 30 seconds until they reach a stop light. As he is cussing more, the old man in the suv puts on a Trump, “ Make America Great Again” hat and scrolls down the window. As soon as the guy in the motorcycle sees it, he then stops cussing and says in a politely manner, “next time be careful.” The caption then says “tough guys for Trump. “ The argument Is that tough guys will vote and stand by Trump. Their is bias to this post because it’s basically saying if you don’t vote for trump or stand for him you are not tough or you won’t be respected by others. As shown he calmed down and began to respect him after seeing he was a trump supporter. I disagree with this post because it doesn’t mean you are not tough or you will not be respected if you don’t vote for Trump, you can vote for anyone you want to. This post uses ethos because it is appealing to those who are Trump supporters.
LikeLike
https://highschool.latimes.com/fountain-valley-high-school/opinion-kobe-bryants-legacy-on-and-off-the-court/
This post is sharing the first Lakers game after Kobe Bryant’s death. The picture shows three players with intense emotion just based off the post. You can see the tears and feel the pain they are feeling. Especially based off of the tight squeezes given to each other, holding one another close together. If you watched the game Lebron James gave a heart felt speech, and literally from the heart, he tore his written speech up and said what he felt in the moment. He had to do this for all that were mourning in the situation. The fans, the players, the family, his wife and kids. Although this was a form of pathos with Kobe Bryant’s death and his daughter the other victims and their families and feeling the same emotions. The game did pay tribute to all in grievance towards this act.
This article shows ethos pathos and logos of emotions of logic and ethics. Last class I researched deeper in what a bandwagon was and found out that now since Kobe Bryant’s passing there seem to be all of these Lakers fans coming out of the wood works that you never seen before. You may have been a Kobe fan and can still be that but that does not make you a Laker fan. So there is a form of being a bandwagon.
LikeLike
In this video posted by YouTube about arsenal vs reading a premier league soccer game, fighting for the last eight to be in the league cup. Arsenal fans where leaving the game within 25- 35 mins of the game based losing already 4-0 in the first half, before halftime finished arsenal scored and first half ended as 4-1. A lot of fans left the game didn’t want to support them, but starting the second half arsenal started with the right mentality and overturned the game. A player named Theo Walcott scored a hat trick within those 45 mins to tie the game and also go into extra time. Despite losing 4-0 to reading in the first half arsenal never gave up and ended up winning the game 7-5 several arsenal fans where surprised they thought they where going to lose and get relegated from being involved in the league cup.
This can relate to the class as we are learning about different types of appeal, such as the appeal of bandwagon as arsenal fans where leaving the stadium due to losing 4-0 within the first 35 mins. This argument trends on how supportive the arsenal fans where to the team, although they weren’t winning several fans stayed and with that support they encouraged themselves and ended winning the game for them.
LikeLike