This week we have been learning about rhetoric and fallacies. Find something that interests you in order to begin understanding how they are persuading us and what their argument is.
You can also look for fallacies out in the wild. Locate and explain the fallacy they are making. Also, how to avoid it.
- Fallacies
- Rhetoric
- Ethos, Logos, Pathos
- Rhetorical Appeals
Requirements: About 250 words, summary and response to the article/post/news/etc; aka text.
Comment below with a link to the text and your summary and response.
https://fox5sandiego.com/news/health/mystery-norcal-coronavirus-patient-in-serious-condition/
In the article “Mystery NorCal coronavirus patient in serious condition” by Christina Maxouris explains of the recent and horrifying case of the corona in Northern California. As a patient who was in a severe condition discovered to be tested positive with the coronavirus. Although she has not been near any coronavirus cities or near anybody who had the virus, she somehow contracted this fatal disease. It is strange about this is that she somehow contracted the disease out of nowhere and isn’t strictly related to anybody with the virus. With this information, it also especially frightening is the other 60 confirmed cases in the US, yet 42 of these are from the Dimond Princess cruise ship. As for now, the patient was sent and to be taken care of at US Davis Medica Center. It is the first case of the coronavirus in the community, which can risk the lives of love ones and others. Also, as the patient is sent to UC Davis on Sunday, they weren’t tested by the CDC until Sunday, which at last confirmed the cases. I choose this article because it relates to ethos, pathos, and logos, as it can be seen throughout the passage of the essay. We can trust the credibility of ethos as this article is by Fox 5 News and has also been confirmed by the CDC. Both news organizations are trustworthy as they are honest and truthful, especially the CDC, who is responsible for controlling and preventing diseases throughout the country. An example of logos is the number of people reported with coronavirus in the US as there are 60 cases in the US, and 42 of these people were from the Dimond princess cruise ship. Finally, pathos is in the way the author addresses the context of the situation as the coronavirus is a danger for the community. It demonstrates pathos by having their emotions in a very frightening and terrifying case.
LikeLike
My brother in law is a big supporter of cannabis for pain management. My sister does not want him to become dependent on the substance, and he has been using very regularly for many years. My sister has asked her partner to give up all substance consumption (weed and alcohol) for an extended period of time to show he is not addicted to either substance. The stance he has taken is, “I could if I wanted to, I do not need it, but I do not want to.” At this point, the back and forth comes, well, “I smoke for legitimate pain concerns.” My sister will reply, “Even when you are in pain, you should not need to use pot. I have been in pain for extended amounts of time without substance consumption, so you should too.” She says she only wants him to have to go through the same things she has, and that is often when he lists his reasons he should not have to experience what she has. In a more recent bicker they had on the subject he brought up, it is not a big deal because they now advertise for it in public spaces even more than alcohol. We were at the mall, and there was a kiosk selling CBD products. Now my brother in law continues to bring the fight back into a debate on whether or not the plant is more widely normalized than alcohol consumption because there are not kiosks selling alcohol. The fact that CBD is sold in more places or a debate on which substance is more accepted was not ever the intentional discussion my sister had in mind. This sidetracking was a fallacy on the part of my brother in law, attempting to okay his actions. I believe the information on CBD normalization was a straw-man fallacy because it replaced the original argument.
LikeLike
An example of a fallacy I think about is the documentary of “Jesus Camp”. How camp counselor used the fear of hell to manipulate the camp goers. Throughout the film, Becky Fischer begins to attack Harry Potter, a fictional character written by Jk Rowlings. She tells the children if Harry Potter is similar to the devil, trying to temp the children into his side. She also declares that if the children are to be good Christians they must fight for Pro-life movement, so they then march in front of the White house in Washington. While in front they place read tape on the mouths of the children and on it they write “LIFE”. She repeatedly states the children must join the army of god, an army to fight those who are not Christian and to take back the country. Fischer say they need to focus on training because the enemy is training, and the children must be committed to dying for God.
I remember seeing this documentary when it first came out, I honestly felt angry, not just for the kids but at the parents who took their children to attend the camp. It seemed that Becky Fischer was try to create a cult by targeting children, children usually are taught not to question their elders so it only made so much easier for her to manipulate them. When they begin to tell the children, they must join the army of God to fight “our enemies”, that when it began to really seem like Fischer was trying to start a cult rather than trying to teach these kids how to be proper people. It was freighting to see that one person was given the power to manipulate these children’s thoughts, and morals.
LikeLike
https://www.msn.com/en-us/lifestyle/lifestyle-buzz/every-single-dog-was-adopted-from-this-shelter-except-one/ar-BB10xdrC?ocid=spartanntp
The article grabs the readers attention by stating how every animal in the shelter had been adopted except for one. This title hooks the readers attention by using pathos to evoke emotions from the reader because the concept of being left alone instills sympathy and sadness. The other part of the title that grabs the readers attention is mystery because they would be curious as to why this animal hasn’t been adopted if many others have already. When reading the article there was no clear reason as to why the dog had not been adopted, but instead they advertised the dog and gave all of the positive points that gave people an idea of what kind of dog it is. They quickly gloss over the fact that the dog is overly curious towards smaller or larger animals. They don’t explicitly say what they mean by this. It is evident that the purpose of this article is to attract attention so that someone will try and adopt the dog and perhaps encourage people to try and adopt a pet from shelters. I personally would adopt the dog if I was able to because the idea of having everyone around you getting chosen while you remain alone is sad thing. Despite all of that the dog has a smile on its face and doesn’t look sad and not matter what the situation is its happy. The majority of this article uses pathos because of the description of the dog and his personality is used so that it grabs the readers attention while using images alongside.
LikeLike
https://sports.yahoo.com/apos-biggest-clown-ever-seen-232451611.html
In this article Steven Zhang, soccer team Inter’s president, criticized Serie A soccer league’s president, Paolo Dal Pino, on how he was handling the Coronavirus crisis in regards to the Italian soccer games. A game for Inter was scheduled with an extra round of matches and Zhang posted several things on his Instagram after Inter wasn’t happy with the schedule. Some of his comments on Instagram were “Playing around the calendar and always putting the public health as secondary consideration. You are probably the biggest and darkest clown i have ever seen. How about we don’t protect our players or coaches and ask them to play for you 24/7 nonstop? Yes i am speaking to you. Our Lega President Paolo Dal Pino. Shame on you. Its time to stand up and take your responsibility! This is what we do in 2020!” Zhangs comments on the issue relates to fallacies we learned in our previous class, ad hominem specifically. Ad Hominem is when you attack a persons character rather than the claims or argument. Zhang attacks the character of Paolo Dal Pino by calling him the biggest and darkest clown because of the actions he has taken regarding the soccer teams. By attacking his character he also hurts Dal Pino’s creditability by adding a negative connotation to his name. Now when we think of Paolo Dal Pino we think of that one time they called him a clown because of the choices he made regardless if they were good or not.
LikeLike
The current President of the United State, President Donald Trump is an individual I consider to be the king of fallacies. He constantly compiles with no fear of being contradicted a bunch of fallacies and present it as facts to the American public. the video above highlights five fallacies President Trump has made.The first fallacy is that we have an invasion of drugs, invasion of gangs and invasion of people and the fact is illegal border crossings at it’s all time low since the begining of the 21st century. the second fallacy is that a big majority of imported drugs don’t go through legal ports of entry, the go thru areas where you have no wall, fact is in 2018, 90% of drugs entering into the United States that were seized were at legal boarders or ports of entry. The third claim is that we are right now in construction building a wall in some of the most important areas, Trump went on to say that he has built a lot of walls because he has a lot of money. The fact is no new miles of fence have been built under Trump’s administration. Fourth fallacy in this video is when asked by a reporter of ways his other constituents feel like Trump is violating the U.S constitution, he claims no one has said that and said that and the truth is House speaker( Nancy Pelosi) did state this and in 2019 Trump was actually impeached. Lastly, Trump said it’s all lies, just a lie Trump went on to imply. Trump said since the reporter was from CNN, they are “fake” news. Fallacies are not legitimate strategies in an sphere but the can be very persuasive and President Trump uses it all the time with no fear of being contradicted.
LikeLike
Ever since learning about Rhetoric in class I feel like I’ve started to notice the use of ethos, logos, and pathos in many things I see every day. For example, I remembered this commercial for Bose headphones staring Colin Kaepernick a quarterback who played for the San Francisco 49ers who is also known for kneeling during the national anthem in protest of police brutality and racial inequality. In the commercial, Kaepernick is seeing riding a bus and outside is a mob of angry people shouting, screaming, and throwing items at the bus towards Kaepernick. You can see the anger and resentment in their faces and the camera zooms up close to them. In a different scene, it shows Kaepernick up close inside the bus looking outside to the mob of people with a serious look on his face listening to their angry shouts. I feel like this commercial does a good job in appealing to both sides of a story while using pathos. It appeals to the angry side of emotions that some may have towards Colin Kaepernick. Many people did not like him after he kneeled for the national anthem and thought what he did was wrong. This controversial event, on the other hand, had a lot of people on his side as well. When the camera showed Kaepernick looking outside the window listening to the people scream at him it appeals to the emotions of those who support him and what he stood for. It makes you think how can someone standing up for something good get that kind of treatment and hate? When Kaepernick puts on the Bose headphones the shouts suddenly diminish and he walks through the crowd with his head held high ignoring the people who are against him and shouting at him. This also appeals to one’s emotions. You can start to think that If he can get through the difficult times and block out all of the hate when standing up for what he believes in, then anyone can overcome those circumstances and you should stand up for what you believe in no matter what.
LikeLike
Ever since learning about Rhetoric in class I feel like I’ve started to notice the use of ethos, logos, and pathos in many things I see every day. For example, I came across this commercial for Bose headphones staring Colin Kaepernick a quarterback who played for the San Francisco 49ers who is also known for kneeling during the national anthem in protest of police brutality and racial inequality. In the commercial, Kaepernick is seeing riding a bus and outside is a mob of angry people shouting, screaming, and throwing items at the bus towards Kaepernick. You can see the anger and resentment in their faces and the camera zooms up close to them. In a different scene, it shows Kaepernick up close inside the bus looking outside to the mob of people with a serious look on his face listening to their angry shouts. I feel like this commercial does a good job in appealing to both sides of a story while using pathos. It appeals to the angry side of emotions that some may have towards Colin Kaepernick. Many people did not like him after he kneeled for the national anthem and thought what he did was wrong. This controversial event, on the other hand, had a lot of people on his side as well. When the camera showed Kaepernick looking outside the window listening to the people scream at him it appeals to the emotions of those who support him and what he stood for. It makes you think how can someone standing up for something good get that kind of treatment and hate? When Kaepernick puts on the Bose headphones the shouts suddenly diminish and he walks through the crowd with his head held high ignoring the people who are against him and shouting at him. This also appeals to one’s emotions. You can start to think that If he can get through the difficult times and block out all of the hate when standing up for what he believes in, then anyone can overcome those circumstances and you should stand up for what you believe in no matter what.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Not sure why it keeps posting the wrong video but the correct one is titled “Colin Kaepernick “I’m the Man” commercial”
LikeLike
Ever since learning about Rhetoric in class I feel like I’ve started to notice the use of ethos, logos, and pathos in many things I see every day. For example, I came across this commercial for Bose headphones staring Colin Kaepernick a quarterback who played for the San Francisco 49ers who is also known for kneeling during the national anthem in protest of police brutality and racial inequality. In the commercial, Kaepernick is seeing riding a bus and outside is a mob of angry people shouting, screaming, and throwing items at the bus towards Kaepernick. You can see the anger and resentment in their faces and the camera zooms up close to them. In a different scene, it shows Kaepernick up close inside the bus looking outside to the mob of people with a serious look on his face listening to their angry shouts. I feel like this commercial does a good job in appealing to both sides of a story while using pathos. It appeals to the angry side of emotions that some may have towards Colin Kaepernick. Many people did not like him after he kneeled for the national anthem and thought what he did was wrong. This controversial event, on the other hand, had a lot of people on his side as well. When the camera showed Kaepernick looking outside the window listening to the people scream at him it appeals to the emotions of those who support him and what he stood for. It makes you think how can someone standing up for something good get that kind of treatment and hate? When Kaepernick puts on the Bose headphones the shouts suddenly diminish and he walks through the crowd with his head held high ignoring the people who are against him and shouting at him. This also appeals to one’s emotions. You can start to think that If he can get through the difficult times and block out all of the hate when standing up for what he believes in, then anyone can overcome those circumstances and you should stand up for what you believe in no matter what.
LikeLike
https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/article/logical-fallacies-gun-debate
I found this article that shows how there are many ways that the news creates fallacies against gun control in order to help a certain candidate win an election. A tactic such as if you are voting for a republican then you are also voting for the murder of innocent people. The two statement do not directly relate, but yet they are telling you this in order for you to not vote for them. Many will believe this type of statement blindly instead of fact checking it like a person should be doing. Another tactic that the media uses is giving two options and only those two options creating a false dilemma. An example would be, either vote that we can no longer have guns in the US, or keep murders happening for no reason. clearly there are other steps in between those to actions that will be able to to resolve the situation. Parents could seek help for them and their children, if you know that someone has a mental problem then go seek help. For some odd reason people wait until the tragedy has already happened for them to seek help. When you know that your child is suffering from a mental illness you should never have an unlocked gun in the house. To blame the all the gun owners as whole for the actions of a single irresponsible gun owner makes no sense. Another big way to create more hate where it shouldn’t be is bandwagon. Many people don’t care for guns whatsoever, but now that it is the trend and all over the media they will hop on the trend of hating guns just because they are scared of what people might think of them. These are some simple tactics that the media tends to use against guns so people should at least try and do their research before believing everything that they here.
LikeLike
In this article, it talks about whether parents should tell their kids the truth about Santa clause. The article then goes on to say that we should tell our kids the truth about Santa clause because they can enjoy Christmas regardless if they know the truth about him, as well as they can end up hurt if they accidentally find out that Santa isn’t really and it can ruin their Christmas. Another reason this article believes this long life fallacy should end is because people use it in a manipulative manner and for any reason they feel their kid is doing wrong they say they won’t be getting anything for Christmas instead of parenting them the right way. One of the last great point this article shows is that research shows that parents who lie to their kids are more then likely going to lie themselves. This is an important part of the article because this fallacy of Santa clause is a huge lie that is built over years. Santa has been around for many years and their will always be a debate if they should tell their kids or not about the truth of Santa clause. At the end of the day it is one of the if not the biggest fallacy in the world.
LikeLike
For this journal I chose Michael Jordan’s speech at Kobe Bryant and his daughter Gianna Bryant’s memorial. I chose this video because it contains ethos. The emotion behind this was devastating. Michael Jordan spoke about what a man he was, how he affected his life, the player on the court and his and his daughter’s relationship. Michael Jordan was a meme a couple years back for crying, being the big man that he is, and “is not supposed to” cry. and everybody used this meme throughout the last three years so this time he tried containing himself. It did not work. The emotion behind this tragedy hit him hard so he ended up making a joke of himself saying he was going to be a meme once again. The emotion is the video is not only with Michael Jordan but with the audience, the fans, his teammates, his family members, wife and daughter.
youtube.com/watch?v=X6kYAS68FKk
LikeLike