Quick Write 1
A theme is the main idea or underlying meaning of a text which may be stated directly or indirectly.
An issue is an important topic or problem for debate or discussion.
Write down two to three important themes, issues, or events from the chapters for today to discuss with the class.
Introduction to Literary Analysis
Prompt
Write an essay about a theme or issue explored in the novel. For this essay, apply your analytical skills to develop a detailed and rigorous argument. Pick something that you find interesting or intriguing from the novel and develop it into a thesis driven essay. The significance or meaning of the topic, in other words what the passage is saying is the central part of this paper. Focus on details, patterns, anomalies, and binaries you notice as evidence to support your thesis’ claims about the ideas that the text is communicating. Identifying the ideas will be the challenging part, because it requires you to move beyond the details to the significance (or the so what question).
You will have to include outside research, one to two articles, public or scholarly to help develop and support your thesis. You need to paraphrase and quote passages from the text to support your claims.
Summary vs Analysis
Summary – shortened version of what happens. The story condensed into a paragraph, or a chapter condensed into a sentence. A scene condensed into a sentence.
ex: Nadia was assaulted at the bank.
Ex: Nadia sleeps with the musician.
Analysis – Breaking things down to component parts to understand why things are happening and what it means.
Ex: Why was the scene of Nadia assaulted at the bank included in the story. Why did the author include it?
Ex: What does Nadia sleeping with the musician reveal about her character? What does this say about her?
- Characters
- Plot, story
- scenes
- lines
- themes
- metaphors
The Book of Unknown Americans
Write a short summary of a chapters so that it will be easier to find key scenes. This will help everyone when we begin looking for scenes to analyze.
Chapters
- Alma (3)
- Mayor (12)
- Rafael Toro (19)
- Alma (24)
- Mayor (37)
- Benny Quinto (44)
Themes and Topics
- Immigration
- ???
Analysis
Look for Patterns: Start sifting through the text looking for Repetitions, Strands, Binaries, and Anomalies.
- Repetitions: “Anisdel Toro” drink in “Hills Like White Elephants,” etc., sheep dog in “How to Talk to a Hunter”
- Binaries: Light/Dark in “Sonny’s Blues,” young/old in “One of Star Wars, One of Doom“
- Anomalies: Mysterious notebook in “One of Star Wars, One of Doom,” tin of chocolates with Santa Claus “fondling” children painted on it in “How to Talk to a Hunter”
- Strands: Animals in “How to Talk to a Hunter,” alcohol in “Sonny’s Blues”
Make the Implicit Explicit: Explain to the reader what the details or the patterns imply. Explain your thought process. Pull out the implications and show them why you think they are “folded in” to the meaning of the text or image. What does this mean and So What? Why is it important?
Quick Write 2
Beginning analysis. Come up with a repetition, binary, anomaly, and strands. Example:
- Repetition: The topic of immigration keeps coming up.
- Binary:
- Anomaly:
- Stand:
Focused Reading and Analysis
Now that you are deciding on a theme or issue to write about from the novel, your reading should be more focused. Every time something related to your topic comes up in the book you should be annotating it. Write down notes about your topic. Write the next reading journal or journals with your topic in mind. Use the rest of the novel and writings to help you begin analyzing the text in relation to your essay. Go back and annotate, underline, and highlight all the references to your theme so that you will have more moments to help you think through the topic.
Sample Essays
The Hidden Complexities of Clemencia
Quick Write 3
Summarize a theme, issue, or character in the novel that you find interesting. Summarize what has been shown so far. Begin to analyze it. What do you think it means? Why is the author writing about it? This could turn into the topic of your paper.
Homework
- Read The Book of Unknown Americans pages 48 – 118 Journal 9 summary/response
Quick Write1
A few major themes I’ve noticed in The Book of Unknown Americans is Immigration, and wanting to be accepted. One of the biggest issues I’ve noticed is how they are treated throughout the duration of the book. Since they are not originally from America, they are treated lesser than.
Quick Write2
Repetition: The topic of immigration keeps coming up.
Binary: How the women are treated vs. How men are treated
Anomaly: Garrett’s interest in Maribel
Stand: Because they are immigrants, people care less about them
Quick Write3
In The Book of Unknown Americans Mayor Toro constantly struggles with acceptance. The kids at his school bully him, his father constantly compares him to his older brother, he himself wishes he was more like him. He talks about not fitting in because he feels more of a connection to America then Panama, but he cannot express that to his family, or people at his school. I feel the author is showing a connection to a key word in the title “Unknown.” Because even though Mayor grew up in the U.S, he is still considered less than because his family was not originally from here. I feel this is the author’s way of showing why the book is titled Unknown Americans.
LikeLike
Quickwrite #1
A few major themes I picked up on within the first chapters were mainly revolving around the bigger picture, immigration. The first was the “American Dream” which is the driving force for many of the characters, secondly was hope since most of the characters always “hope for the best” either for someone else, a situation or themselves. Lastly, the other theme I noticed was change since most of the characters must constantly deal with change and difficulties throughout.
Quickwrite #2
Repetition: The topic of immigration keeps reappearing.
Binary: How immigrants are treated unfairly .vs. how non-immigrants are treated fairly.
Anomaly: Garret’s character, actions, and overall motives.
Stand: The benefits, progress, and opportunities immigrants are deprived from.
Quickwrite #3
I found Chapter 3, Rafael Toro’s stories the most interesting so far because he remembers how his father was ill tempered. Therefore, Toro believes that’s why he also carries this “chip on his shoulder”, I think this can be an important theme included by the author. Since my many single-parents immigrants children may find themselves in a similar situation because of their circumstances.
LikeLike
Quick Write 1
The main theme of the book is immigration. Since in its different chapters various stories are told of people from different countries, who come to the United States in search of a better life. Another important issue that I felt identified with is discrimination, since many of these people went through some situation of discrimination when they got here.
Another important issue is the barrier of English, since the stories narrate some of the limitations that they have had to go through because they do not know English.
Quick Write 2
• Repetition: The topic of immigration keeps coming up.
• Binary: in search of the American dream vs. the reality that immigrants live in the USA
• Anomaly: Alma chapter, his journey across the border and how he faced the new reality by living here.
• Stand: the reality of life that immigrants face when arriving in a new country where culture, language and beliefs are totally different.
Quick Write 3
The topic that called me the most was the one of Alma, due to the way in which the entire course that she and her family had to go through to get here is narrated, in addition to the narration of all the difficulties they had to face when they started their new life here. There are many themes in history with which I feel identified, for example, not knowing English, which is one of the barriers that I have had a hard time avoiding. Another thing that caught my attention in this chapter is the work that her husband got, because even though he did not look at the light sun for more than 10 hours and that he could not eat and drink, just because he fulfilled his dream American he put up with all that for his family.
LikeLike
Quick Write #1
Theme: I figured main ideas of themes are immigration, and pursue of the american dream.
Issues: discrimination, disabilities, drugs, and bullying.
Quick Write#2
*Repetitions: Definitely immigration has been mention several times.
*Binary: legal immigrants vs illegal immigrants, one’s immigrant history vs another ‘s immigrant history.
*Anomalies: How Arturo and Alma refers to Maribel’s disability.
*Strands: the different scenario once those people had and their new reality .
Quick Write #3
So far I do identify with Alma. The struggles she is going not only the language barrier, foremost important the unknowing education o treatment her daughter Maribel may encounter. Also, I empathize with the history of Rafael Toro. How he remembered Panama even after many years have past, and how he assimilate as an immigrants living in a foreign country that now he calls home.
LikeLike
Quick Writes
1.The main theme in “The Book of Unknown Americans” is to tell the different stories of different immigrants. An issue that they face is harassment by people that are not the same color as them. Another issue is that they do not speak any english and do not know where anything is at.
2.Topic: Major trying to impress his dad and living under the shadow of his older brother. The more obvious topic is immigration.
Binaries: The differences between the way men are treated and the way women are treated.
Anomaly: Garrets interest and motives.
Stand: The different challenges the immigrant families have to face.
3. An issue that stands out to me is that Maribel seems to be this beautiful girl that everyone can not take their eyes off, but there is something clearly wrong with her that has not yet been said. Do they look at her because of her beauty? Or is do they look at her because of her disability?
LikeLike
quickwrite 1:
Two important themes in this story are the view of the “American Dream” and immigration. The characters in this book are trying to grasp hold of the :American Dream” and leave their life while facing immigration.
quickwrite 2:
repetition: Immigration is a repetitive topic within this book.
binary: How immigrants were treated compared to the treatment of non-immigrants
anomaly: the characteristics and actions taken by Garrett
stand: the opportunities immigrants are unable to take part of
quickwrite 3:
Within this story, the overall explanation of the different scenarios each of these characters faced really helped get a better insight of that they dealt with. I believe the incidents Mayor Toro went through really stood out to me because I constantly hear of different stories from my own grandfather about the difficulties he overcame when he came here to the United States form Mexico as a child and the very hard transition that it was and I feel they went through similar issues within bullying or discrimination from others.
LikeLike
Quick Write #1
The theme of The Book Of Unknown Americans is immigration and its distinct storylines. An issue being faced is being discriminated against.
Quick Write #2
Repetition: The theme of immigration is being mentioned frequently.
Binary: The discrimination of immigrants and the focus of trying to live the American dream, but
Anomaly: Garrett’s interest in Maribel
Stand: The differentiation on how they the immigrants used to live compared to how they are facing life now.
Quick Write #3
In The Book Of Unknown Americans, Almas’ story stands out to me the most with the difficulties and struggles she encounters not only with herself not being able to speak English, but with her family and daughter who is special needs.
LikeLike