Summary vs Analysis
Summary – shortened version of what happens. The story condensed into a paragraph, or a chapter condensed into a sentence. A scene condensed into a sentence.
ex: Nadia was assaulted at the bank.
Ex: Nadia sleeps with the musician.
Analysis – Breaking things down to component parts to understand why things are happening and what it means.
Ex: Why was the scene of Nadia assaulted at the bank included in the story. Why did the author include it?
Ex: What does Nadia sleeping with the musician reveal about her character? What does this say about her?
- Characters
- Plot, story
- scenes
- lines
- themes
- metaphors
Analysis
Look for Patterns: Start sifting through the text looking for Repetitions, Strands, Binaries, and Anomalies.
- Repetitions: “Anisdel Toro” drink in “Hills Like White Elephants,” etc., sheep dog in “How to Talk to a Hunter”
- Binaries: Light/Dark in “Sonny’s Blues,” young/old in “One of Star Wars, One of Doom“
- Anomalies: Mysterious notebook in “One of Star Wars, One of Doom,” tin of chocolates with Santa Claus “fondling” children painted on it in “How to Talk to a Hunter”
- Strands: Animals in “How to Talk to a Hunter,” alcohol in “Sonny’s Blues”
Make the Implicit Explicit: Explain to the reader what the details or the patterns imply. Explain your thought process. Pull out the implications and show them why you think they are “folded in” to the meaning of the text or image. What does this mean and So What? Why is it important?
Quick Write
Beginning analysis. Come up with a repetition, binary, anomaly, and strands. Example:
- Repetition: The topic of immigration keeps coming up.
- Binary:
- Anomaly:
- Stand:
Focused Reading and Analysis
Now that you are deciding on a theme or issue to write about from the novel, your reading should be more focused. Every time something related to your topic comes up in the book you should be annotating it. Write down notes about your topic. Write the next reading journal or journals with your topic in mind. Use the rest of the novel and writings to help you begin analyzing the text in relation to your essay. Go back and annotate, underline, and highlight all the references to your theme so that you will have more moments to help you think through the topic.
Quick Write
Summarize a theme, issue, or character in the novel that you find interesting. Summarize what has been shown so far. Begin to analyze it. What do you think it means? Why is the author writing about it? This could turn into the topic of your paper.
Homework
- Read The Book of Unknown Americans 108 – 155 Journal 11