Logically Fallacious by Bo Bennett
Intro to Fallacies
Key Terms
- Argument: A conclusion together with the premises that support it.
- Premise: A reason offered as support for another claim.
- Conclusion: A claim that is supported by a premise.
- Valid: An argument whose premises genuinely support its conclusion.
- Unsound: An argument that has at least one false premise.
- Fallacy: An argument that relies upon faulty reasoning.
- Booby-trap: An argument that, while not a fallacy itself, might lead an inattentive reader to commit a fallacy.
The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy – Fallacies
This is a great resource for further reading on fallacies and how they are not so simple. The article lists 223 of the most common fallacies.
I do not expect you to know them all or to never use any. Fallacies are controversial. We appreciate logic and honesty in Western rhetorical thinking and that is at odds with many fallacies.
Fallacies are not wrong, they work very well and are very good at persuading people. Fallacies are considered unethical, and so we try to avoid them. They are thought of as flaws in thought, tricks, and sneaky uses of persuasion to convince others. Generally, we try to avoid the most common ones.
We looked at Ad Hominen and Hasty Generalizations last class.
Pathos or Emotional Appeals
Pathos represents an appeal to the emotions of the audience and elicits feelings that already reside in them.
Pathos speaking emotions overview
-
Select Emotional Themes and Points
-
Choose Words which Add Emotional Emphasis
-
Use Rich Analogies and Metaphors
-
Tell Stories
-
Use Humor
-
Connect through Visuals
-
Model the Emotion with Your Delivery Techniques
Appeals to pathos target the link between audience members and their values (Hauser, 2002).
When we act on our values, we experience emotions like happiness, pride, satisfaction, etc. When we do
not, we often feel shame, fear, or anger. The same goes for the actions of people around us: we are
often pleased when the actions of people around us align with our values and angry when they
don’t.
Emotional Fallacies (Pathos)
Scare Tactics – Scaring people and exaggerating dangers.

Either-or Choices / False Dichotomy – Oversimplification to only two choices.

Slippery Slope – Exaggerating the consequences of an action.
Sentimental Appeals – Excessive emotion intended to distract.
Bandwagon Appeals – Follow the path of everyone else.
Ethical Fallacies (Ethos)
False Authority – Offering yourself or other authorities as sufficient evidence.
Dogmatism – persuade by assuming a position based in biblical passages.

Moral Equivocation – suggesting that serious wrongdoings do not differ from minor ones.
Ad Hominem (At the person) – Attacks directed at character instead of the claims or argument.
Logical Fallacies (Logos)
Hasty Generalizations – conclusions drawn from insufficient evidence. Jumping to conclusions. The most common fallacy you will encounter.
Faulty Causality – assuming because one event happened after another, the first causes the second.
Begging the Question – a form of circular logic. an argument based on claims that cannot be accepted as true.
Equivocation – the use of ambiguous language to conceal the truth or to avoid committing oneself.
Non Sequitur – an argument in which claims, reasons, or warrants fail to connect logically.
The Straw Man – Misrepresenting an argument in order to knock it down. Arguing something that is not really there.
Faulty Analogy – An extended comparison that is inaccurate or inconsequential.
Red Herring – Partway through an argument, the arguer goes off on a tangent, raising a side issue that distracts the audience from what’s really at stake. Often, the arguer never returns to the original issue.
Which Fallacy(ies) is this?
Example: “Grading this exam on a curve would be the most fair thing to do. After all, classes go more smoothly when the students and the professor are getting along well.”

Let’s try our premise-conclusion outlining to see what’s wrong with this argument:
Premise: Classes go more smoothly when the students and the professor are getting along well.
Conclusion: Grading this exam on a curve would be the most fair thing to do.
When we lay it out this way, it’s pretty obvious that the arguer went off on a tangent—the fact that something helps people get along doesn’t necessarily make it more fair; fairness and justice sometimes require us to do things that cause conflict. But the audience may feel like the issue of teachers and students agreeing is important and be distracted from the fact that the arguer has not given any evidence as to why a curve would be fair.
Tip: Try laying your premises and conclusion out in an outline-like form. How many issues do you see being raised in your argument? Can you explain how each premise supports the conclusion?
Developing Solutions
- Summarize your problem into one sentence
- Describe why it is a problem (how does it violate your values, morals, or definition of
culture?) - Who is your audience (the person or group of people you are appealing to for help solving
the problem) - What are the values and interests of that specific audience (in a perfect world, what does
that audience care about? What makes them tick?) - How can you appeal to the audience’s values and interests when making your argument? In
other words, what is in it for your audience to agree with your position/argument?
Strategy Example
- Argument from Principle
- Argument from Consequence
- Argument from Precedent
Homework
- Read Part 7, Research and Sources
- Conduct Research
- Fill out research worksheet

1. Why can’t America use high school for their general education instead of doing it all over again in college?
2. This is a problem because it takes much more money and time to get to what you want to do in life.
3. My audience is my peers and the future of this generation
4. The values of my audience is caring about what can help us become who we want to become in life faster and in a more efficient way.
5. My audience, by agreeing with me, would be able to get done with their degrees a lot faster because they would be able to go into the direction they want in life right out of high school.
LikeLike
Social media makes people more inclined to be anti-social. This is a problem because people need to be more social and open to new experiences when dealing with real life. I think my audience will be young adults and anyone who uses social media regularly.
LikeLike
Summarize your problem into one sentence:
– That there is too much pressure for girls to have perfect bodies due to magazines and social media.
Describe why it is a problem (how does it violate your values, morals, or definition of
culture?)
– This is a problem because teenagers can put themselves into danger by focusing too much on their bodies.
Who is your audience (the person or group of people you are appealing to for help solving
the problem)
– Teenage girls.
What are the values and interests of that specific audience (in a perfect world, what does
that audience care about? What makes them tick?)
– My audience cares about what other people think and they care about how they look.
How can you appeal to the audience’s values and interests when making your argument? In
other words, what is in it for your audience to agree with your position/argument?
– Relate to them on how they are not alone in this, but show that it is not as important as they think it is on having the perfect body.
LikeLike
1) How should schools address bullying?
2) Bullying is a problem in schools because school administrators are not talking to the students they are talking to the parents. They do not bring enough awareness to the problem.
3) School administrators and facility
4) My values and interests for this audience is to show schools that most students are too scared to open up about bullying. Schools and parents need to stand together, show videos and assemblies on bullying and the effects of bullying.
5) What I want to show for my audience is that if their child was getting bullied and they did not know until it was too late, they would have wanted to stop bullying. If the audience agrees with me, we can stop bullying and show awareness that this is something to not joke about.
LikeLike
1) Video games do not cause real life problems.
2) This is a problem because people are using this as a scapegoat and to not take responsibility for their own actions. This comes as a result that makes video games have a bad image.
3) People who see video games as a problem
4) Violence that is caused in the real world.
5) Stop seeing video games as a scapegoat at see what the real problem is.
LikeLike
vegetarianism food shortages
1 prevent global food and water crisis
2 its a problem because we can potentially run out of food and water
3 everyone
4 the audience must care about not running out of food and water
5 by giving them tons of research on this topic.
LikeLike
1. Puppy mills across the U.S. are a danger to dogs as they regard profits over the well-being of the dogs.
2. This is a problem because it is viewed as inhumane as these dogs are suffering and dying for the sake of making money.
3. My audience consists of pet owners and anyone that looks to purchase dogs from pet stores.
4. The values and interests of my audience are the concern and safety of all animals they adopt or purchase.
5. I can appeal to my audience by showing them what happens to the dogs that come from puppy mills and how they are treated.
LikeLike
1)My problem is how to increase the amount of women in STEM jobs/fields.
2)Its a problem because there isn’t really a big focus on women getting into a STEM field.
3)My audience would be women and educators. because i feel that Educators should try to influence women to get into STEM.
4)The values would be that if Men and Women want to be equal then why arent they trying to compete with men into getting STEM jobs.
5)I can appeal to the audience’s values is by using examples and data showing and comparing the amount of men and women in stem.
LikeLike
1) Should doctors be allowed to assist terminally ill patients with painless suicide through euthanasia?
2) It is a problem because euthanasia is not allowed in enough countries around the world.
3) My audience is anyone who is concerned about euthanasia.
4) The interest of the audience is that they are arguing whether euthanasia should be allowed world wide.
5) My audience can agree with points I make which can help them get their arguments about euthanasia across.
LikeLike
1. Cali is heavy on laws while other states aren’t.
2. It is a problem because all other states should require the same laws across the US so it can be a safe place.
3. My audience are state law makers.
4. The value and interest of that audience is making laws for their own specific state, but I’m talking about having it all the same across the country.
5. The audience should agree because we are trying to make this country a better place so it should start with the laws.
LikeLike
Deforestation
The world’s forests continue to vanish at a threatening speed.
Forests have irreplaceable role in human and animal lives. The increasing global warming and climate changes with all of its effects due to deforestation are endangering their lives.
My audience is college students who care about environmental issues and want to know more about the solutions.
LikeLike
1. Summarize your problem into one sentence.
The problem I’m overviewing is Mass Extinction of nonhuman species.
2. Describe why it is a problem (how does it violate your values, morals, or definition of coulture?
This is a problem because it takes a toll on the rest of other ecosystems. (circle of life)
3. Who is your audience (the person or group of people you are appealing to for help solving the problem)
My audience would be the world because Global Warming has a lot of effect on Mass Extinction and Global Warming is caused mainly by humans.
4. What are the values and interests of that specific audience (in a perfect world, what does that audience care about? What makes them tick?)
I think this interests the audience because people care about animals.
5. How can you appeal to the audience’s values and interests when making your argument? In other words, what is in it for your audience to agree with your position/argument?
I think people need to realize that animals are dying because of human effect on the environment (Global Warming). We can find ways to reduce Global Warming so that Mass Extinction doesn’t have to be a problem in the world.
LikeLike
People do not vaccinate their children and put them and others at risk for contracting infectious diseases.
It’s a problem because they are unnecissarily putting people at risk for something that is preventable.
Who is your audience (the person or group of people you are appealing to for help solving
the problem)
In a perfect world, the audience cares about the health and wellbeing of those around them. The possibility of others getting sick for no reason makes them tick.
I can appeal to the audience’s values and interests by including stories of small children or the elderly getting sick because they were unable to get vaccinated and someone who chose not to get vaccinated contracted an infectious disease and passed it onto the elderly person or child.
LikeLike
1) Single household parents negatively affect children.
2)The problem with this is that it can change the way a child thinks of marriage and being committed in a marriage.
3)My audience our country.
4)I say it interest people because they can know that living separated can damage the minds of young people.
LikeLike
Slippery Slope
Definition: when an event is suggested to lead to a more significant event, which eventually leads to an even bigger event.
Example: If you allow the students to redo this test, they are going to want to redo every assignment for the rest of the year.
LikeLike
Bandwagon is a fallacy, or mistake, in argumentation. Related to the emotional appeal in persuasion, or pathos, the bandwagon approach involves convincing a readership that the majority of people agree with the writer’s argument
LikeLike
1) appeals to false authority means someone in power is telling you something that it may not necessarily be true but you believe them because they may have a high status or title like a cop.
LikeLike
LikeLike
Ad Hominem is an argument used to oppose another argument. Often used to attack a person’s character rather than the person’s issue. An example of this is “Killary for Prison”.
LikeLike
Logical Fallacy #12 is the “Bandwagon Appeal”. This fallacy is the argument that an idea is valid because of its popularity or that many people believe it. An example of this is “cheating doesn’t affect people because everyone is doing it nowadays”.
LikeLike
A faulty analogy is a comparison between two things that are similar therefore they must have more in common with each other. Example: Making people register their own guns is like the Nazis making the Jews register with their government. This policy is crazy.
LikeLike
Slippery Slope
Definition: when an event is suggested to lead to a more significant event, which eventually leads to an even bigger event.
Example: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/349099408597683254/
LikeLike
Exaggerating or misrepresenting someone’s argument to make it easier to attack.
LikeLike
#7. Hasty Generalization
Definition: Making a conclusion based on a small sample size.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwjX8vWIq7TTAhXHv1QKHc39A9IQjRwIBw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fowl.excelsior.edu%2Fargument-and-critical-thinking%2Flogical-fallacies%2Flogical-fallacies-hasty-generalization%2F&psig=AFQjCNGSgTdqHBGhUOv6kkuEWhjmBEnVPQ&ust=1492822430582632
LikeLike
#6. Sentimental/emotional appeals – Promotional activity aimed at highlighting emotional factors (such as looks, status value, popularity) of a product, instead of the logical or practical factors.
Example: Grocery store commercial that shows a happy family sitting around the table at Thanksgiving.
LikeLike
Example: After Will said that we should put more money into health and education, Warren responded by saying that he was surprised that Will hates our country so much that he wants to leave it defenceless by cutting military spending.
LikeLike
4.) Either or choices
By having a choice and having two things to compare to a desired need.
Example : If someone wants to go to a good college but cant decide they have “choices” to choose from if they got accepted to more than two.
LikeLike
Appeal to Authority
Definition: Citing an authority figure without them actually being an authority on the subject you’re arguing for. In other words, your authority is irrelevant.
Example: My fifth grade teacher once told me that girls will go crazy for boys if they learn how to dance. Therefore, if you want to make the ladies go crazy for you, learn how to dance.
LikeLike
#3 Dogmatism the expression of an opinion or belief as if it were fact.
https://goo.gl/images/5XqBZF
LikeLike
Scare tactics
A tactic used to scare people influenced by fear
Example – a teacher tells her students “I’m going to call the principle if you children don’t quite down “
LikeLike
Ad Hominem- Appealing to ones prejudices, emotions,or special interests rather than to ones intellect or reason
Example- https://youtu.be/-nQGBZQrtT0
Donald Trump “Your such a nasty woman”
LikeLike
Definition: When you are arguing to scare your audience with fear and not based on evidence.
Example:
Timmy: Mom, what if I don’t believe in God?
Mom: Then you burn in Hell forever. Why do you ask?
Timmy: No reason
http://linoit.com/entry/image/7720375
LikeLike
e·quiv·o·ca·tion
-the use of equivocal or ambiguous expressions, especially in order to mislead or hedge; prevarication. Examples: I have the right to watch “The Real World.”
e·va·sion
-an act or instance of escaping, avoiding, or shirking something:
evasion of one’s duty.
Example: In face of this no evasion was possible.
LikeLike
Either/or choices: assuming falsely that a choice must be made between opposites.
– two alternatives.
ex: “You’re either part of the solution or part of the problem.”
LikeLike
equivocation
-the use of equivocal or ambiguous expressions, especially in order to mislead or hedge; prevarication.
Examples: I have the right to watch “The Real World.”
evasion
-an act or instance of escaping, avoiding, or shirking something:
evasion of one’s duty.
Example: In face of this no evasion was possible.
LikeLike
FAULTY CAUSE:mistakes correlation or association for causation, by assuming that because one thing follows another it was caused by the other.
LikeLike
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwj-4Pa1r7TTAhXizlQKHZuXD-kQjRwIBw&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.quora.com%2FWhat-is-the-regression-fallacy&psig=AFQjCNH5yV65fYiMoBcKe7SvsD2yLGoAwQ&ust=1492823588843815
LikeLike
6. Sentimental or Emotional Appeals : Of or prompted by feelings of tenderness, sadness, or nostalgia. Or relating to a person’s emotions.
Ex. A commercial showing African kids and how you can buy for them 15 cent a month.
LikeLike
1) Do we need art in our lives?
2) I believe we need art in our lives because art can vary from music to drawing and showing your emotions.
3) My audience would be my reader that wants to find more about art and the meanings behind its purpose and without we have nothing.
4) everything we use to be social with our friends was created by art.
5) A lot of people don’t realize how much art is in our lives.
LikeLike
1) how come california or america itself offer free college or universities?
2)This is a problem because not a lot of people can afford going to college. if college was free more people would be able to get an education.
3)my audience would be college students that are currently paying for college.
LikeLike
1. The problem is that people want to lower the crime rate by taking away the guns of citizens.
2. This is a problem because statistics show that gun control does not lower the crime rate, and it also goes against the constitution.
3. The audience is the young people who agree with the changing culture that guns are bad.
4. That specific audience cares about world peace and valid things such as coexistence
5. I can use statistics to justify my position that gun control does not save lives but rather endangers them. There is definitely a need for a certain amount of control over guns however there is a fine red line that crosses what the constitution gives us.
LikeLike
Why do we waste so much food?
We sometimes tend to buy so much food that we end up throwing a big percentage to the garbage. As Americans, we don’t give it a second though when we throw away because our easy access to getting more food for consumption.
The general person/anyone who does their own grocery shopping
the problem)
They care about the environment and morality of not wasting food
Showing statistics exactly how much food is being wasted every week/year, offer incentive why it’s beneficial not to waste food/offer solution to assist people to make the right decision when groceries shopping.
LikeLike
1) Herd immunity is becoming compromised and otherwise preventable diseased are becoming more prominent due to the anti-vaccination movement.
2) This is a problem because by not vaccinating your children and compromising herd immunity, you put other lives in danger. Not everyone has access to or is physically capable of receiving vaccines and they rely heavily on herd immunity.
3) My audience are the members of this anti- vaccination movement who do not wish to vaccinate their children.
4) This audience believes that vaccines do more harm than good to their children’s bodies.
5) I can appeal to this audience by explaining that they are actually harming the health and well-being of their children by not vaccinating them, and vaccinations are less of a threat than they perceive.
LikeLike
for my paper the problem is that hospitals waist blood products by giving it to patients who are going to die no matter what interventions are made.
it is a problem because the public gets harassed to donate but the patients get charged multiple thousands of dollars to get it whether they live or die.
LikeLike
1.) We don’t have enough organs.
2.) The problem is people today have little or no regard for the value of human life. Most people are selfish.
3.) My audience is humanity but mainly classmates.
4.) The audience cares about saving family and friends.
5.) My solution is to use logos and convince the person to agree to harvesting organs of criminals and death row inmates. They committed a crime in live , so they should be given a chance for redemption in death.
LikeLike
1) Should Student Athletes get paid?
2) I believe student-athletes should get paid just because of how much money they generate from TV ratings.
3) Student athletes or just about everyone involved in sports.
4) Being a athlete but in school also is very difficult so if you are in school and playing a sport the one thing you must do is work hard. Also one thing you hate to see when no one gives you credit for what you do day in and day out.
5) I have multiple reasons why student athletes should get paid, first of all who does not want money and secondly i am pretty sure every athlete believes they should have a salary for hard they work.
LikeLike
1) Justice not properly being handed nor served for the crimes committed by the people that sworn in to uphold the laws
2) The problem is that the justice system is being partial to sum while ab normally severe to others
3) The audience i am aiming for is everyone, this problem applies to all parties because we are all indirectly affected
4) Justice, equality, fair treatment to all man
5) a potential change within the system that we live in, we must first start with changing the minds of the masses
LikeLike
I haven’t decide yet what to write about.
LikeLike
Problem: Most long distance relationship end up breaking up.
it is a problem because the majority of these couples breaking up when they could have a chance to can save their relationship.
Audience: people who skeptical of long distance relationships, couples in LDR and not.
LikeLike
I’m doing my argumentative essay on deforestation and how it effects our society. This is a problem because so many animal species are being chased away from their homes and also deforestation causes many other effects to the economy.
LikeLike
1. Summarize your problem into one sentence.
Too many teens are becoming pregnant at a young age.
2. Describe why it is a problem (how does it violate your values, morals, or definition of couture?
teens who are under 18 have trouble getting birth control because of the need of a parent concent.
3. Who is your audience (the person or group of people you are appealing to for help solving the problem)
My audience would be teens and their parents.
4. What are the values and interests of that specific audience (in a perfect world, what does that audience care about? What makes them tick?)
parents believing their children are too young to have sex
5. How can you appeal to the audience’s values and interests when making your argument? In other words, what is in it for your audience to agree with your position/argument?
By eliminating the need of a parents approval teens can get birth control themselves and this can create less pregnancies
LikeLike
1) children being placed back with abusive parents
2) the courts might not find enough physical evidence so they cant place them with cps so they hand them back to thier parents that might nit be as fit
3) all parents and people that abuse children
LikeLike