Critical comes from the Greek word krinein, meaning “to separate, to choose”; above all, it implies conscious inquiry (4).
Conscious also means to be awake or aware. This suggests that by examining our reasoning, we can understand the basis of our judgments and decisions – ultimately, so that we can make better ones.
Issue: Gay Marriage Licenses
In a 2015 case from Kentucky, Kim Davis refused to begin issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples.
Who has a say in the matter? What is affected by this issue?
Let’s work on the three questions on pages 8-9.
Issue: Flying Spaghetti Monsters
Pastafarians? Should they be recognized as a “real” religion?
Identifying and Examining Assumptions
What assumptions do you see in the Spaghetti Monsters section?
Critical Thinking and Ignorance
“Most of us assume whatever we believe to be “right.” Though we were taught much of what we believe before we could critically analyze our beliefs, we nevertheless defend out beliefs as the truth” (Elder and Paul).
Intellectual Humility: awareness of the extent of your ignorance.
People with a high degree of intellectual humility understand that there is far more that they will never know that they will ever know (Elder and Paul).
- Acknowledge that you may be wrong, until you find sufficient evidence to prove your belief.
- Notice when you argue if you are justifying your beliefs. Do you have evidence?
- Question your beliefs, especially religious, cultural, or political.
- Research from multiple perspectives.
- Explore new beliefs.
Identify weaknesses in your thinking.
- What do I truly know?
- Are my prejudices and biases influencing my thinking?
- What beliefs have I accepted without critical thinking?
- How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
Examine Life
The unexamined life is not worth living.
a famous dictum apparently uttered by Socrates at his trial for impiety and corrupting youth, for which he was subsequently sentenced to death, as described in Plato’s Apology.
BLM
Homework
- Journal 1 response by Saturday.
- Read Chapter 2 from Current Issues and Enduring Questions.
- Read Carl Sagan chapter from the syllabus.
My beliefs have been shaped from birth because they are a direct reflection of my parents’ beliefs and the beliefs of those around me during my upbringing. Where I was born, the time period, my race, my family, etc.; all play a role in determining the way that I think and the ideals and norms that I have been accustomed to and adopted. An even scarier thought is that all of these variables are entirely out of my control yet they are the most dominant deciding factors in defining the person that I am today.
LikeLike
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
Well it comes to a sense of super ego where you learn so much from people you have grown close to. Those people shape the way you view certain aspects on life and how you may perceive certain ways of believing. Some might be more opened to certain ways of thinking depending on how they were raised/taught.
LikeLike
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth. Basically, somebody told me their experience about something, and their beliefs. I will just ignore what they said until I made mistake, then I will remember what they have told me long time ago.
LikeLike
Overall I think we all have different beliefs and that’s because we are all raised differently and I think that depends from what kind of religion you are but we all kind of have the same morals. I think that for me my beliefs have changed from birth and I think that has to do with everything I see on social media. Most of my family is religious and therefore believe in the bible and I think that really influences them on how they think, but because I am younger I am able to view things in a different perspective.
LikeLike
My beliefs have strongly influenced my life. I am a Christian and I morally believe in loving everyone and showing everyone respect. Everyone generally has a good heart but we aren’t perfect and we make bad decisions/judgements. Since I am a Christian I believe we are born in to sin but that doesn’t mean we aren’t good people. I was taught that there are people that aren’t as fortunate as I am or that are ignorant to a lot of things.
LikeLike
My beliefs have been shaped from birth with almost everything I still believe in. Mostly with the idea of God and my political stance. I do not remember a time where I didn’t know of God since I was raised catholic and I still do believe in him and as I grew up my beliefs were shaped politically. I heard what my parents were telling me and heard their opinions that they shared with me and to this day I still agree with them on that.
LikeLike
My mother has raised my up to believe that women are independent. We can do anything on our own if we put our mind to it and we don’t have to rely on a man for support. She would always tell me to do good in school so that I can get a good education and make a decent living. As a little girl I would work hard at school to make my mom proud. Now that I am 19 I strive to achieve and maintain a 4.0 GPA so that I can graduate. I still hold true to the belief that I can sustain on my own and live comfortably.
LikeLike
My beliefs have been shaped from birth because of my family, people around me, and personal experiences I have been through since birth. From the moment that I was born words of god where whispered in my ear. My parents have been teaching me and the rest of my siblings everything we need to know about islam and how to be a good muslim since as young as we could comprehend. Non-religious wise my beliefs about the world and people around me was also taught and shaped in the sense that i used to look at people and life the way that my parents did. The thing that shaped me the most was the morals that i wast taught. Those where taught to me every single day for 16 years so now they are a part of me. For example, through words of wisdom or discipline i have been molded into the person i am today.
LikeLike
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
My beliefs have been shaped by having parents that were Christian and it kind of set me up to be a Christian and follow that religion. Also the culture that determines who we are and what we become.
LikeLike
My belief system has always been Christianity since I was born. In addition, the way it has shaped my life is the influence and exposure from parents teaching me guidance and morals to be a subordinate kid to their authority and read and apply what Jesus teaches in his word. For instance, I would not explore other belief systems because I do not find it adequate enough for my life, therefore I do not involve myself in them. Yes, my parents religious beliefs were a huge influence on my life, however, it is shaped by discernment and intuition on how I feel and how I apply it to my everyday life.
LikeLike
4. In the beginning of my life I thought all of my beliefs were true; such as my political views, religious views, and several other social norms. However, the older I got the more I realized a lot of my beliefs were biased. Until I faced a lot of obstacles throughout my life, I started to second guess my pre-existing beliefs. Things like believing in the justice system and having faith that they would always search for justice, became very untrue to me. Realizing that the justice system is just another social institution that discriminates against blacks. My political beliefs have also shifted with the older I got, I used to believe I was a democrat because my mom was a democrat, however as I got older and started to see how political actually work I realized I am in the middle and I don’t have a specific political party I belong to. These and several other strong beliefs I had are constantly changing; which tells me that nothing is certain.
LikeLike
My beliefs have been shaped through what my parents do and what they have taught me as I grew up. My parents passed down what they believed and a lot of that came from the Indian culture and everyday life of India. They moved here when they were about my age so they didn’t get to grow up in the American culture all they got do here was work and then raise two kids. A lot of what I learned of the American culture was through TV and when I was old enough school. School has influenced what my beliefs are and how I think and how I perform certain actions. Most of youth is spent at school and doing school activity’s so that’s what really makes you who you are.
LikeLike
Since I could remember my family has really only pushed their religious beliefs on me especially growing up in a Catholic home, there were certain “rules” i had to follow and things I couldn’t do. Other than that my parent are actually very open minded people when it comes to personal beliefs, but if its a topic pertaining to politics It’s something they actually dont like to bring up as much just to avoid controversy at home.
LikeLike
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
My family wasn’t big on the religious views that some families have and therefore my views on a higher power are different than others. If my family would’ve focused their teachings on believing in a religion and having me learn more about it than maybe I would’ve had a different opinion on the subject. I don’t believe that it is wrong for people to believe in a certain matter that is different than mine, but I feel that if they are blindly believing in something just because it was the way they were raised, than they are not thinking for themselves and following a biased decision.
LikeLike
I think that most of my beliefs have been shaped from birth, in that the environment and the people around me have influenced what I thought and the way I thought about them. Some of my values come from what my parents believe and what they have taught me; others come from what I have seen in school or in the community. After you reach a certain age, you start to question whether the beliefs you grew up with are ‘right’ or not and you begin the develop your own beliefs based on your observations. Each person has a different background and upbringing, so we are all bound to have different beliefs.
LikeLike
What do I truly believe?
I believe mostly the concepts I was taught as a child that have been proven to be factual or have impacted or benefited me positively throughout my life. I truly believe that a person’s beliefs don’t necessarily define who they are but how they decide to have their beliefs impact other people’s lives or society on a whole.
Are my prejudices and biases influencing my thinking?
Many time prejudices and biases have a huge impact on a person’s thinking but I try to indulge in critical thinking and not my prejudices and biases as this will be the only way to have reasonable facts and substantial information that can be agreed on by others and not just myself. My prejudices and biases do not influence my thinking all the time but it’s usually dependent on the topic or situation at hand.
What beliefs have I accepted without critical thinking?
The beliefs I have accepted without critical thinking are those that were instilled since birth and accepted by the majority of society, have been proven to be true and cannot be denied no matter how much evidence people try to come up with that goes against it e.g. Equality, this belief does not need to be substantiated with critical thinking or evidence.
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
My beliefs have been shaped from birth through set examples that were and are still being set by my parents and other authoritative individuals that are credible and trustworthy. Being able to see how positively these beliefs have influenced or impacted not just myself but other people helped to shape who I was and who I am and wo I will become.
LikeLike
I was born into Christianity from my parents, so my beliefs in life and how I view the world are shaped from Christianity. For some examples I believe we are all equal, we must love others no matter what the circumstance is and forgive them, we only marry opposite sex and etc. Christianity is the main vocal point of my beliefs and aspects of the world.
LikeLike
Yes. My beliefs where shaped by Parents, Religion, School, Relationships and other general influences. For example, I was raised as a catholic, but there are some issues that I do not agree on. My beliefs are more based on experience, and things that I am strongly interested in understanding.
LikeLike
How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
I grew up around three strong, lively, resilient, hardworking, stubborn, feisty, independent, loving, emotional, dramatic, beautiful, at times impoverished, confident, flawed, joyful, dysfunctional, intelligent, food loving, Mexican American women known as my mother, my grandmother and my aunt. The most important characteristic among these three women that I have listed is strong. They are essentially survivors. I carry many of their beliefs. I have had and discarded some of their beliefs and some I never acquired. I hold primarily liberal viewpoints politically and socially which have been mainly encouraged by my mother and brother. I previously identified as a Christian like my family but I no longer do. I do not believe in some traditional female roles some of my family has believed in. I do highly value education and love nature and animals like my family. But no matter what, these women raised me and I am what they were and are in so many ways.
LikeLike
4. How have my beliefs been shaped from birth?
My beliefs from birth have shaped my life in many different ways good and bad because as I gotten older I’ve found myself doing these things that I’ve seen my parents and others do. As I get older some things I have changed because now I am more opened to things that I’ve seen that thought was right but wasn’t right because I am able to recognize the many effects that it has on me as in adult.
LikeLike
My core beliefs have been shaped from birth by a combination of the teachings from my parents, society, and just personal experiences. The forming of these core beliefs may include anywhere from common morals, ethics, and may continue to venture even further into things such as religion, political views, etc. When growing up, my parents didn’t approach discussions or speaking about opposing viewpoints with a very open mindset, which always caused me to be very hesitant to listening to their beliefs. Within every argument, I found myself finding flaws such as them not backing their beliefs or biases with evidence, or just generally avoiding addressing the opposing side’s arguments through the uses of fallacies as you spoke about. Over time, I was able to be more comfortable with expressing and voicing my similarities and differences in opinions due to school. This had also taught me more about myself and gotten me to be open to learning about my strengths and weaknesses. Furthermore, I learned how to avoid approaching an open discussion–without ignorance and a closed mind. Overall, these negative experiences had pushed me to reevaluate their beliefs as well as my own, and had also shown me how to be open and willing to change.
LikeLike